Your top 10 P4P list

[Hous]

1) Floyd Mayweather
2) Manny Pacquiao
3) Joe Calzaghe
4) Jermain Taylor
5) Ricky Hatton
6) Marco Antonio Barerra
7) Winky Wright
8) Tomasz Adamek
9) Jose Luis Castillo
10) Rafael Marquez

Tarver is good, but not even top 20 p4p for me.
He beat a washed up Roy Jones that hasn't won a fight in 3 years. And hes 50 / 50 with Glen Johnson. IMO Glen Johnson is better than Tarver an i realize the first time they fought one of the judges was watching another fight. the scorecard was 116-112, 113-115, 113-115. It shouldn't have been a SD.

[moy22487]

PBF
winky
pac
mab
hatton
marquez
castillo
taylor
thats what i got so far

[Gio]

PAc has accomplished more than PBF in his career. thats the reason why i rank him higher.



Peace

Very true.

[Gio]

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Marco Antonio Barrera
5. Rafael Marquez
6. Ricky Hatton
7. Jermain Taylor
8. Jose Luis Castillo
9. Diego Corrales
10. Martin Castillo

I pretty much agree with this with exception of Manny at #1 .

[armani_model]

1. Mayweather
2. Winky
3. Pacman
4. Berrara
5. Hatton
6. Castillo
7. Calzaghe
8. Corrales
9. Cotto
10. Me!!

[AREALFIGHTER]

PBF
PAC
WINK
MAB
locked for the top four
Hatton, Calz, Taylor middle of the pack in any order
JLC, RM, Tarver, as you will in the bottom half.
Just outside Bhop, John, Arce, I vasquez= iffy but the guy is good and I like him. Calderon. If John can get an other big victory he goes straight to the middle depending on what the men their do. Vasques is in a similar boat. If tarver wins he locks the 7 spot. The only one that can really fall out of top 4 is wink if he looses. MAB PAC PBF could survive loses and keep their spots depending on other fighters on this list.

[AREALFIGHTER]

PBF
PAC
WINK
MAB
locked for the top four
Hatton, Calz, Taylor middle of the pack in any order
JLC, RM, Tarver, as you will in the bottom half.
Just outside Bhop, John, Arce, I vasquez= iffy but the guy is good and I like him. Calderon. If John can get an other big victory he goes straight to the middle depending on what the men their do. Vasques is in a similar boat. If tarver wins he locks the 7 spot. The only one that can really fall out of top 4 is wink if he looses. MAB PAC PBF could survive loses and keep their spots depending on other fighters on this list.

Forgot about abraham If he gets a good fight and wins he is up there to but there are many many good fighters that depending on wins and losses of those in the top could easily pop right in there are a lot of good fighters out there like realy good.

[Easy-E]

You guys are on crack or racialy biased to put Calzaghie below 5... Thats ridiculous.

he has one big win over a guy who wasnt p4p top ten.

[Gio]

he has one big win over a guy who wasnt p4p top ten.

thats exactly why he shouldn't be listed.

[Easy-E]

Very true.

PBF has accomplished more in his career, manny more recenrly. Just look at manny's championship fight record. 2-1-1. Not overly impressive. Floyd holds wins over Corrales, Castillo, Jesus Chavez and Genaro Hernandez.