Your top 10 P4P list

[oldgringo]

Floyd Mayweather
Winky Wright
Manny Pacquiao
Marco Antonio Barrera
Rafael Marquez
Joe Calzaghe
Jose Luis Castillo
Ricky Hatton
Jorge Arce
Antonio Tarver

[OptimusWolf]

[To IWatchBoxing]

Interesting list. How can you put Toney at #1 though. He's coming off a sc****d draw against a mediocre heavy champ, and hasn't beaten anyone of consequence since Jirov unless I've missed something.

Corrales - great entertainment but not top 10 p4p.

Judah is very good in my opinion but can't be in the top 10 after two clear straight defeats!

If you've done this on your favourite 10 fighters then fair enough, forget my comments they're BS.

Incidentally, I hope Cotto makes it later this year by beating Castillo, he's probably my favourite fighter right now, he's got so many good punches and combinations available to him.

[IwatchBoxing]

James Toney, 37 years, went from Middleweight to Heaveyweight, nomatter what your opinion is of the divsion right now, Heaveyweightts will always be the best in boxing.

Corrales legitly beat Casamayor and Castillo, Castillo fraudly beat both of them. If Castillo legitly wins the 3rd fight he can come on.

Judah drew or beat Mayweather.

I also changed it a bit.

[Easy-E]

And your list is????

Those names are the top names in each division.

Cotto, Vasquez and Calderon are all questionable and having JLC third is laughable.

Floyd
Pac
Winky
Taylor
Hatton
Joe C
MAB
Raf Marquez
JLC
Tarver

[Bhopsfan]

PAc has accomplished more than PBF in his career. thats the reason why i rank him higher.



Peace

[oldgringo]

Cotto, Vasquez and Calderon are all questionable and having JLC third is laughable.

Floyd
Pac
Winky
Taylor
Hatton
Joe C
MAB
Raf Marquez
JLC
Tarver

Taylor at 4 is a joke, while we're at it.

[drez24]

Judah drew or beat Mayweather.

You mind giving your round by round scores?

[IwatchBoxing]

You mind giving your round by round scores?

Lets just say, that I gave Judah like 5 rounds, and Floyd 1, missed two rounds after that, didnt count the knockdown, took the roit out of my mind, and still felt a draw would of been good.

[Easy-E]

Taylor at 4 is a joke, while we're at it.

Hes there more by default than anything else. He has the 2 wins over the middleweight champ, and no one else has a resume like that below him.

[oldgringo]

Hes there more by default than anything else. He has the 2 wins over the middleweight champ, and no one else has a resume like that below him.

Rafael MArquez and Marco Antonio Barrera would probably have something to say about that.

They have both beaten HOF fighters as well, but have accomplished INFINITELY more in their careers to this point than has Taylor.