Has there been a fighter who did less than GGG to be considered top 5 p4p

[therealpugilist]

Ike Quartey 1997.

I die everytime I see that Morris Day gif LMAO

[US Dirk Killer]

Terrence Crawford.

He's done much, much, much, much less

[therealpugilist]

Terrence Crawford.

He's done much, much, much, much less

Crawford isn't top 5

[KidDinamita]

naw, its entertaining watching his die hard fans reach and flail for reasons to validate his hype and p4p placement

He is a good fighter and IMO he is the best middleweight in the world.....he isn't the champion, Canelo earned it....he has to as well......Matter of fact Canelo should be higher than GGG....He has fought better competition, is the real champion and only lost to the greatest fighter of the passing generation.

Canelo earned it? how? by fighting Matthew Hatton for a world title? and fighting past their prime fighters that were in other weight classes? or wait? by only fighting at his 155lbs class? The only time he fought at a different weight class and stepped up his competition he lost.

Mind you I like the guy because he achieved a lot for his age, but if he starts to fight more frequently he will accomplish more, instead of fighting once a year.

[therealpugilist]

Canelo earned it? how? by fighting Matthew Hatton for a world title? and fighting past their prime fighters that were in other weight classes? or wait? by only fighting at his 155lbs class? The only time he fought at a different weight class and stepped up his competition he lost.

Mind you I like the guy because he achieved a lot for his age, but if he starts to fight more frequently he will accomplish more, instead of fighting once a year.

I was strictly speaking on his middleweight venture, he is the champion.


Yea that fight with Hatton was a joke, just like Margarito fighting Pac for the same belt at 150 when neither guy were ranked or did anything past 147


His wins over Lara, Angulo, Trout, Rhodes, Mosley and Cintron made up for that bull title fight



For a young fighter, he does have a pretty good resume and is already a titleholder in two divisons....the catchweight thing is silly to me but he has fought good fighers.



His resume is better than GGG's and he is like 9 years younger

[xhiddenx87]

Has there been a poster that made more GGG topics than you? I think the answer is no.

Yes, Larry...he makes like two by week

[Kuyukut]

one fighter comes to mind... fraud mayweather!

[xhiddenx87]

Look, he is in the P4P list because of the way he beats his opponents, TOP10 MW look like **** when they fight him, even the ones that have good opponents on their resumes, besides he make them quit to a TKO.

that is why most P4P list rank him in his TOP10-TOP5

We may not like his resume but he has the skills and power to move a couple spots.

[DreamerUSA]

this is a legitimate question....He is a unified titleholder, albeit not the champion of his division...he is exciting and makes for good TV but his quality of opposition is lacking


How in the world is GGG ranked so high when guys Like Amir Khan, Danny Garcia, Tim Bradley, Takashi Uchiyama, Shinsuke Yamanaka, Adonis Stevenson etc. not on the list when they have fought better competition


Estrada is lower and is a two division titlist and has beaten more champions than he has


Canelo and Rigondeaux also are rated under him by boxingscene and other publications even though they are the PROVEN man in their divison and have defeated and faced stiffer competition

He does'nt belong in the top 5 imo. Anyways I can certainly agree that I would include Yamanaka, Uchiyama and Bradley, but at the end of the day there are only 10 spots and probably 20 guys you could make a legit case for being in the top 10.

[TheUntouchable]

Why do you care so much about an imaginary bull**** list?

Ranking all those guys from different weight divisions, what for? Most boxers (including all those guys you mentioned and Floyd and Manny and ...) never fight the best out of their own weight class, why even bother thinking about a ranking for all weight classes?


There's so much talking about who should be P4P #1, 2, 3, 4, ..., 100, who's A-side, B-side, X-side, Y-side, Z-side, all those absurd rankings are for nothing, fans should demand the best fights and not troll each other with all that bs.