Could Prime May/Oscar/Pac go 4-0 vs Winky/Forest?

[The Viper]

There is a reason oscar avoided winky.
Winky boxes circles around his ass and wins 11-1

lol i don't think it would be 11-1 come on now show a little respect for oscar's boxing skills, if you think winky beats him that's fine, i could see that for sure
If a old oscar can win rounds off of a prime may he can win rounds off of winky

[AddiX]

Forrest And Wright are just too big for those guys.

Mosley couldn't even hurt winky, and he def landed some shots.

[GOD-FR33]

Another good thread....

[SIZE="4"]This is yet another good thread! This has been a good day on NBS. Now, on to the question.

Could Prime May/Oscar/Pac go 4-0 vs Winky/Forest?[/SIZE]


Mosley was so fun to watch in his prime BUT he wasn't as smart as Oscar, May, or Manny. Oscar/Wright and Oscar/Forrest almost happened!!! I think Oscar could outpoint Wright. If Taylor almost did it, Oscar could DEF do it. As for Forrest, I think that was a 50/50 fight. Again, I'd lean toward Oscar against Forrest. Forrest was a terrific fighter BUT he has never fought an Oscar De La Hoya. I think both Winky and Forrest beat Floyd and Manny. Manny gets a pass because he wasn't a Welterweight or a 154lb fighter. The guy is a LIGHTWEIGHT. Hats off to him for his bravery and incredible skill to do what he's done against larger men. It isn't even fair to him to suggest he'd fight Winky, who spent most of his career at 154lbs. That fight wouldn't have even happened. Wright is too BIG for Manny and so is Forrest BUT the Forrest fight was at least realistic. They both beat Manny and Floyd. Prime Oscar beats both Floyd and Manny also. Great thread here.

[285Kid]

Oscar is 5'10 vs Winky 5'10 & Forest 6'0

Floyd 5'8 & Manny 5'5

[The Viper]

[SIZE="4"]This is yet another good thread! This has been a good day on NBS. Now, on to the question.

Could Prime May/Oscar/Pac go 4-0 vs Winky/Forest?[/SIZE]


Mosley was so fun to watch in his prime BUT he wasn't as smart as Oscar, May, or Manny. Oscar/Wright and Oscar/Forrest almost happened!!! I think Oscar could outpoint Wright. If Taylor almost did it, Oscar could DEF do it. As for Forrest, I think he that was a 50/50 fight. Again, I'd lean toward Oscar against Forrest. Forrest was a terrific fighter BUT he has never fought an Oscar De La Hoya. I think both Winky and Forrest beat Floyd and Manny. Manny gets a pass because he wasn't a Welterweight or a 154lb fighter. The guy is a LIGHTWEIGHT. Hats off to him for his bravery and incredible skill to do what he's done against larger men. It isn't even fair to him to suggest he'd fight Winky, who spent most of his career at 154lbs. That fight wouldn't have even happened. Wright is too BIG for Manny and so is Forrest BUT the Forrest fight was at least realistic. They both beat Manny and Floyd. Prime Oscar beats both Floyd and Manny also. Great thread here.

I agree manny is to small for winky, but remember manny fought margarito and beat him margs was prolly bigger than i ever saw winky at 154. but i see your point.......

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I agree manny is to small for winky, but remember manny fought margarito and beat him margs was prolly bigger than i ever saw winky at 154. but i see your point.......

Margs has about 1/10th of the skill that winky has

[The Viper]

Margs has about 1/10th of the skill that winky has

I agree with you 100%

[GOD-FR33]

Yup.

I agree manny is to small for winky, but remember manny fought margarito and beat him margs was prolly bigger than i ever saw winky at 154. but i see your point.......

Yeah. Cheeto was 170lbs against Manny. LoL. Smh. It was scary every second of the fight. Manny fought his heart out though. But Winky was so much more skilled than Cheeto. Yes? On top of that, his defense was like Clottey's. You see how clever Manny fought Clottey though? He was like, you won't give me your head, I'll hit your body and your gloves against your head. Manny's ring IQ is under-estimated.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Yeah. Cheeto was 170lbs against Manny. LoL. Smh. It was scary every second of the fight. Manny fought his heart out though. But Winky was so much more skilled than Cheeto. Yes? On top of that, his defense was like Clottey's. You see how clever Manny fought Clottey though? He was like, you won't give me your head, I'll hit your body and your gloves against your head. Manny's ring IQ is under-estimated.

While clottey and winky share some characteristics, winky was better n smarter..

Clottey would cover up vs manny and doesn't return fire until manny was done punching.. But manny never stopped punching, so clottey was covered up a ridiculous amount of time, waiting for manny to stop punching.. That's why manny threw like 1200 punches that fight.. Clottey just shelled up, waiting for a break..
Winky would shell up, but would look to counter inbetween your shots, not waiting till you were finished punching..

[GOD-FR33]

While clottey and winky share some characteristics, winky was better n smarter..

Clottey would cover up vs manny and doesn't return fire until manny was done punching.. But manny never stopped punching, so clottey was covered up a ridiculous amount of time, waiting for manny to stop punching.. That's why manny threw like 1200 punches that fight.. Clottey just shelled up, waiting for a break..
Winky would shell up, but would look to counter inbetween your shots, not waiting till you were finished punching..

I agree with this. So, do you also believe that Wright would be too big and wins?