Could Prime May/Oscar/Pac go 4-0 vs Winky/Forest?

[The Viper]

Prime Mosley went 0-4 against these guys, he was great fighter in his prime but he had no answer for them honestly IMO these where prolly shane's toughest fights not to mention I think a prime winky/forest is prolly better than everyone on may's, pac's and maybe even oscar's resume.

So the question is do you think a prime may could beat these two and beat them in the respective rematches and go 4-0 against them? Could he make it look easy like he did in the canelo fight?

Also bonus question. Could Prime oscar or pac do it?

[imperial1]

Oscar had the better chance based on height and reach ..Floyd would never fight them he would find an excuse not to then he'd say they ducked him

[aldo5408]

There is a reason oscar avoided winky.
Winky boxes circles around his ass and wins 11-1

[Sugar Adam Ali]

No..

Oscar has the best chance since he can match the size of winky n forrest...


Forrest and winky would be too big and too skilled for manny n floyd IMO

[The Viper]

I'm a big fan of all of those fighters, but i think the only welters/super welter's that for a fact go 4-0 against winky/forest is a prime SRR/SRL/Hearns. I don't think may/pac/oscar could do it....maybe may but it would not be easy that's for sure

[latinbrawler316]

Oscar, Floyd, Manny lose to a prime Winky. Floyd ducked Winky anyway Winky agreed to the split and the rehydration clause then Floyd wanted a different split, the talks ended and Floyd went on to fight Sharmba Mitchell, sound familiar

[hhs661]

With Winkys style I think he defeats all of them. Forest is a wild card. His height and reach give him the edge vs pac. A prime odlh gives him a great fight. Forest might lose in a controversial decision and Floyd has the best chance to defeat him if he fights him how he did odlh, imo.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

There is a reason oscar avoided winky.
Winky boxes circles around his ass and wins 11-1

Actually Oscar offered winky a fight way before winky fought mosely and tito..

Oscar offered it to him as a unification at 154 after the vargas fight, and winky would have gotten a career high payday.. But winky turned it down..


How long have you been watching boxing?? It's commonly known as one of the worst boxing business decisions in recent times, and coined the term " winky's school of business"

Oscar ended up fighting yory boy campos once winky turned him down

[Wolfie*]

Always thought Vernon Forrest had the best shot of actually KO'ing Mayweather. His reach, height, and power would be too much for Floyd.

[AddiX]

There is a reason oscar avoided winky.
Winky boxes circles around his ass and wins 11-1

That's ridiculous, Oscar didn't avoid anyone, he fought Quartey who winky stole his style from. It would def a tough fight for Oscar though, but I don't how anyone can say Oscar avoided anyone.