Could a absolute prime Oscar Clean out current welter?

[b00g13man]

Giving Shane Mosley credit for the De La Hoya fight is like giving Margarito credit for the Cotto fight. Against Trinidad Oscar had the fight in the bag and everyone knows what happened. Oscar was not a 160 pounder and the Hopkins fight should not have happened. Against Floyd he was over the hill already and still gave a great fight and arguably won. Do I really need to point out everything about the PAC fight?

So there you have it, Oscar practically retired undefeated and beat everyone that mattered when it mattered most.

Looooooooooool. That was hilarious.

On topic, I think he'd beat everyone with the exception of Floyd.

[Jc8804]

A past prime very well past it singing part time fighting oscar won 5 rounds vs floyd. He was winning after 7 rounds

No doubt a prime oscar handles him.
That would be floyds first fight vs a prime hall of famer.
Literally

[LacedUp]

I would favor a prime golden boy over anyone right now 147-160.

147 - Probably would still pick Mayweather to beat him. 154, sure he would probably win clean it out if we count Canelo as a MW.

160? Against GGG/Cotto/Canelo and come out 3-0?

Not a chance.

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

Yes............................................... .

[IMDAZED]

Probably given that the top welters are well past their prime and the others aren't quite there yet.

[LacedUp]

Probably given that the top welters are well past their prime and the others aren't quite there yet.

Plenty of prime welters out there, Khan, Porter, Thurman, Brook, Bradley (if even on the slide).

[Jc8804]

147 - Probably would still pick Mayweather to beat him. 154, sure he would probably win clean it out if we count Canelo as a MW.

160? Against GGG/Cotto/Canelo and come out 3-0?

Not a chance.

Oscar beats cotto at any weight. Canelo is easy work. Canelos best win was josesito lopez and alfonzo gomez (two 140 pounders ) at 154. How people think trout lost to canelo is laughable. In texas. Lara clealry beat canelo.its called boxing.


GGG would be a challenge. Maywearher struggled with an old part time past it oscar . Singing oscar.

[IMDAZED]

Plenty of prime welters out there, Khan, Porter, Thurman, Brook, Bradley (if even on the slide).

I guess. I don't think any of them beating a prime Oscar. And while all are top ten contenders, I don't see them as the elite of the division (yet).

[BOXEO _]

Adrien Broner beats him.

[BOXEO _]

Prime Oscar whips everybody at 147 and 154. Prime Oscar beats prime Floyd and Manny too.