Comments Thread For: De La Hoya on Mayweather: He's Not TBE, I Beat Him!

[!! Shawn]

yaddah yaddah yaddah....I wouldn't pay attention to anyone ripping Mayweather's record when he clearly has the best welterweight resume in this era....Matter fact better than all the fighters he supposedly ducked or was afraid of....I laugh at it when people say he ducked Margarito...so Floyd wasn't scared of Pacquaio, Canelo, Oscar, Mosley, and Cotto who are better fighters but he is scared of Margo who was wholly average....str8 comedic

Eh, honestly, best ww resume of the era would go to Oscar or Shane.

Oscar:
Mosley
Trinidad
Whitaker
Quartey
Mayweather
Chavez

Mosley:
Oscar
Pacquiao
Margarito
Cotto
Forrest
Mayweather

Mayweather is:
Oscar
Cotto
Pacquaio
Mosley

[therealpugilist]

Whats your point though? You think Oscar was fresh? 34 going on 35, with a whole career of big fights against the best fighters under his belt?

Oscar was faster and harder hitting at 135 also...

So I dont really see your point about mayweather not being prime... because I dont know what that would make oscar.

The point was neither were at their prime

Unless you think Floyd is immortal


Bob arum prevented it from happening

Soon as both were independent they fought ASAP

[royjonesjrKTFO]

Oscar LOST 9 rounds to 3, to Floyd. But beat Pernell, 7 - 5, in my opinion. The Pernell Whitaker fight was razor thin close. Pernell didn't make Oscar pay enough for missing.

[therealpugilist]

Eh, honestly, best ww resume of the era would go to Oscar or Shane.

Oscar:
Mosley
Trinidad
Whitaker
Quartey
Mayweather
Chavez

Mosley:
Oscar
Pacquiao
Margarito
Cotto
Forrest
Mayweather

Mayweather is:
Oscar
Cotto
Pacquaio
Mosley

So losses matter more than wins? Only on NSB

He has a better resume than both @ ww and sww

Floyd also has more defenses n beat more top ten welterweights than they did @ 154 he faced the best in the division each time there

[aboutfkntime]

Eh, honestly, best ww resume of the era would go to Oscar or Shane.

Oscar:
Mosley
Trinidad
Whitaker
Quartey
Mayweather
Chavez

Mosley:
Oscar
Pacquiao
Margarito
Cotto
Forrest
Mayweather

Mayweather is:
Oscar
Cotto
Pacquaio
Mosley

Nah, Mayweather actually won his fights.

But on a similar note.....

Check out Hoya's resume overall..... fcuk me, that dude fought everyone.

[TLC8]

you do realize a lot of the guys you named were natural welterweights or higher and these weights were their best weights....Mayweather didn't get to WW til he was 28-29 and it was his 4th weight class...

Floyd started as a pro between 126-130 so if youre gonna mythically match him try letting it be a prime Floyd, at his best weights.....130-140....Floyd was almost 30 when he moved to 147 and it was his 4th weight class

Its like saying Nonito Donaire would have never had the balls to face Sandy Saddler, Willie Pep, or Naseem Hamed knowning Darn well 126 was never Nonito's best weight and 5th weight...stuff like this never made sense to me

****** Phukk, Floyd refers to himself as a Welterweight. He thinks he's invincible at Welterweight. You don't hear him talking about himself at 130. You hear him boasting he walks around at 150, beating everyone at 147 is no problem he says. He says he'd even fight Oscar at 154 tomorrow, yet says he's not fighting GGG at 154. So nobody gives a phukk where Floyd started. He refers to himself as the best right where he is at 147. That being said, he's not even close to being the best ever at 147. So do your homework clown.

[Boxing lives]

Eh, honestly, best ww resume of the era would go to Oscar or Shane.

Oscar:
Mosley
Trinidad
Whitaker
Quartey
Mayweather
Chavez

Mosley:
Oscar
Pacquiao
Margarito
Cotto
Forrest
Mayweather

Mayweather is:
Oscar
Cotto
Pacquaio
Mosley

don't forget about guerrero

[big_james10]

Come on, we're back on this again. You lost Oscar, get over it...and take Pacman with you.

Don't forget about Alvarez.

[robbyheartbaby]

The history books read otherwise Oscar, you got up on one card and that was luck. Mayweather is great.

[LouIE G]

Thats what i thought watching Live, but then i watched it a few more times and oscar won 4 or 5 rounds tops. Floyd beat him, and thsts that.