Comments Thread For: Mayweather: I Beat The Big 3 - Pacquiao, Canelo, Cotto

[ButtScratcher^^]

The first Castillio fight just reenforces the fact that 10 point system isn't used effectively. The rounds you could give Floyd were close, but Castillio clearly beat Mayweather up in the later rounds and showed he was a class above Floyd that night and should have left with his title.

No way should Floyd been rewarded the decision, he knew.

You would have to give Floyd every close round to have him winning which I didn't. I score close worlds for the champion as it should be.

And that is why:

We now have the technology in our hands and this isn't 1800's anymore, change the scoring system and find a way to incorporate replay system with it; --every modern sports now have incorporated replay in their scoring system, why does the most dangerous sport in modern times, where every punch thrown can cause hematoma and death to human being still doesn't have the luxury of a truly accurate objective scoring system? Basketball has one now, Tennis has one now and a countless many other modern sports, and that's ridiculous because that's not so dangerous as boxing.

If they can find a way to incorporate a replay system, we could eliminate 99.9 percent of those controversial and cheating perceived decisions. It's only fair, because these guys lives are in peril in every damnnn time on every second of the fight; and sometimes, one fight alone can determine where the direction of their life is heading, because for most of them, there is no life after boxing, and it's too damnnn hard to live knowing that in your heart you had it, but they took it away from you unfairly. They deserve fairness more than ever period.

[komandante]

You did not beat Pacquiao in-spite of all the intimidations from NSAC.

[Spoon23]

Close fight to me. I gave Floyd 1-4 8 10 12. Gave Castillo 5-7 9 11. Scored it 114-112. Castillo did his damage in rounds 5-7. The rounds Floyd won he won on close, but Castillo outlanded him by a lot in the rounds he won IMO. Good fight but I couldn't find 7 rounds for Castillo. And I don't think HBO ever considered Floyd an investment. Leading up to the ndou fight they were talking about how lackluster he was Bc of his defense once his hand issues started.

Yup Floyd lost against Castillo. That's one loss.

[Spoon23]

Lost to Maidana due to excessive hugging.

That's 2 losses.

[SilverMiles]

manny vs world champs: 20-5-2
Won against Chatchai Sasakul, Lehlo Ledwaba, Jorge Eliecer Julio, Marco Antonio Barrera (twice), Erik Morales (twice), Oscar Larios, Juan Manuel Marquez (twice), David Diaz, Oscar De La Hoya, Ricky Hatton, Miguel Cotto, Joshua Clottey, Antonio Margarito, Shane Mosley, Brandon Rios, Timothy Bradley and Chris Algieri.

Lost against Medgoen Singsurat, Erik Morales, Timothy Bradley and Juan Manuel Marquez, Floyd Mayweather Jr.

Drew against Agapito Sanchez and Juan Manuel Marquez

floyd vs world champs: 23-0
Won against Genaro Hernandez, Gregorio Vargas, Diego Corrales, Carlos Hernandez, Jesus Chavez, Jose Luis Castillo (twice), DeMarcus Corley, Arturo Gatti, Sharmba Mitchell, Zab Judah, Carlos Manuel Baldomir, Oscar De La Hoya, Ricky Hatton, Juan Manuel Marquez, Shane Mosley, Victor Ortiz, Miguel Cotto, Robert Guerrero, Saul Alvarez, Marcos Rene Maidana (twice), and Manny Pacquiao.


bruhhhhhh

You missed Jorge Solis- WBA Super Featherweight Champion

And Marquez +1

[The Problem Child]

A drained to death 152 version of Canelo who can't even fight at 154 anymore. Has been fighhting at 155 ever since.

A fat version of Cotto trained by an amateur trainer who even himself admitted he was better off with Roach lol.

And most people saw a ONE ARMED Pacquiao beat floyd so that is as embarrassing as it gets. He was asking Pacquiao for the rematch as soon as the injury was exposed.

He hasn't beaten any of them legitimately, and that's non debatable.

[Spoon23]

actually lost to a handicapped Pacman due (torn rotator cuff)

That's 3 losses

6-7-8 investigation


1-2 invstigation


3 investigation

[bigboxerABC]

Has nothing to do with what I expected it's what I saw that told me Castillo won the fight. We can talk about ESPN or whatever but the HBO crew was shocked they didn't even say anything for minutes after the decision was announced. Even they couldn't justify the decision and it was in their best interest for Floyd to win The crowd everybody knows Castillo won that fight. It it what it is, for people to consider him TBE is a joke. De La Hoya would have beaten him and he was passed his prime and cracked out and Floyd barely won that fight, De La Hoya kills him in his prime.

Ike Quartey owned De La Hoya and you can take that to the bank.

[FrenchDeLaHoya]

instead of the retirement after hatton, fight cotto

instead of marquez after "retirement", fight pac

canelo? fight him whenever you want at 154 tho.

khan & thurman waiting for you boy. not berto lol

[ButtScratcher^^]

actually lost to a handicapped Pacman due (torn rotator cuff)

That's 3 losses

6-7-8 investigation


1-2 invstigation


3 investigation

And that is why:

We now have the technology in our hands and this isn't 1800's anymore, change the scoring system and find a way to incorporate replay system with it; --every modern sports now have incorporated replay in their scoring system, why does the most dangerous sport in modern times, where every punch thrown can cause hematoma and death to human being still doesn't have the luxury of a truly accurate objective scoring system? Basketball has one now, Tennis has one now and a countless many other modern sports, and that's ridiculous because that's not so dangerous as boxing.

If they can find a way to incorporate a replay system, we could eliminate 99.9 percent of those controversial and cheating perceived decisions. It's only fair, because these guys lives are in peril in every damnnn time on every second of the fight; and sometimes, one fight alone can determine where the direction of their life is heading, because for most of them, there is no life after boxing, and it's too damnnn hard to live knowing that in your heart you had it, but they took it away from you unfairly. They deserve fairness more than ever period.