Most Underrated Boxer & Overrated Boxer Currently ?

[Beater_of_ass]

Overrated - JMM
Underrated - Cotto (He's top 5 P4P) People will say no but make a list. Only haters won't have in there at all. He's better than Bradley. JMM and Froch are gone and as stated JMM is overrated as hell anyway.

[Jc8804]

Overrated : Danny Garcia because of Cherry pickings and Gift decisions.

Is that larry in the red hat

[Mr.Fantastic]

Overrated - JMM
Underrated - Cotto (He's top 5 P4P) People will say no but make a list. Only haters won't have in there at all. He's better than Bradley. JMM and Froch are gone and as stated JMM is overrated as hell anyway.

@ top 5 P4P.

How many P4P boxers did Cotto beat at the time he fought them?

Cotto is overrated/overhyped but he's your pedestal model so I know I'm talking to a wall.

[BrometheusBob.]

Overrated - JMM
Underrated - Cotto (He's top 5 P4P) People will say no but make a list. Only haters won't have in there at all. He's better than Bradley. JMM and Froch are gone and as stated JMM is overrated as hell anyway.

[Beater_of_ass]

@ top 5 P4P.

How many P4P boxers did Cotto beat at the time he fought them?

Cotto is overrated/overhyped but he's your pedestal model so I know I'm talking to a wall.

Sergio was P4P, Mosley was P4P... How many P4P has GGG beaten? Vlad? Bradley (cleanly?) JMM? Crawford? Forget winning how many have those guys even faced P4P. I'll wait for you P4P list before talking ****. Cotto has fought more top 10 P4P guys than anyone in boxing with the exception of Floyd. He's beaten more than Canelo as well... and JMM. And anyone else not named Floyd Mayweather.

But hey, I knew the haters would be out in full force people can't handle the truth. It's all good. Hell, Larry just made a ****ing thread about Floyd's resume and Cotto beat almost everyone there except for Manny and Floyd themselves. And Floyd is number 1 and Cotto actually faced Margarito and Martinez... and Mosley 4 years prior. Yea, he lost one of those which is why he isn't number 1. Makes him top 5. Where's your list?

[Beater_of_ass]

Other than Floyd, Vlad and Manny who has done more? I'll be waiting for your list as well.

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Underrated: Chavez Jr. lol

Overrated: GGG, but still respect the man a lot.

[sicko]

I don't think Jose Pedraza is underrated, he just worked his way up the right way and finally got his chance to showcase his talent to the world on Wilder undercard and he impressed! He did it the right way instead of getting hype early and then picking easy opponents to protect your hype like some fighters.

Underrated: Nicholas Walters! I still feel like Walters is very underrated! He doesn't get the hype other fighters get at all, he has a fun and exciting style, he has boxing skills as well as the power to take anyone head off at 126 but yet he don't get hyped like others on HBO and I don't see many P4P Rankings with him in the Top 10...Why Is That?

Overrated: It is some guys that I think are overrated not because they're not good but more so because of their crazed fans who are ready to put these guys on All Time Great List Now without them having to earn it. So far Canelo Alvarez has fallen flat in Big Fights, lets see how he does vs Cotto maybe the Cotto fight will be his coming out party and him solidifying himself as the next Superstar in boxing, but if he falls flat again in a big fight then it is time to get rid of Chepo Reynoso!

[BrometheusBob.]

Other than Floyd, Vlad and Manny who has done more? I'll be waiting for your list as well.

My P4P list currenty looks like:
1. PBF
2. Klitschko
3. Roman Gonzalez
4. GGG
5. Kovalev
6. Manny Pacquiao
7. Rigondeaux
8. Inoue
9. Uchiyama
10. Crawford

Off for inactivity:
JMM, Froch, Ward

Honorable Mentions:
Yamanaka
Canelo
Cotto
Povetkin
Garcia

[HEND]

Excellent choice for underrated. I would say Uchiyama but he's recently made it onto the p4p list, so I'll pick Inoue instead. He's not underrated so much on these forums, but he doesn't generate as much mainstream attention as he deserves.

Overrated is tough to say... maybe Rigondeaux is a bit overrated, at least as far as what his resume is concerned. Wilder and Frampton are honorable mentions.

Wilder? Who hypes Wilder? Most users even hate him here.
Rigondeau? I would argue with that.
Even if you like Golovkin better than Rigondeaux you can tell that Golovkin is objectively more overrated. Start from the fact that Rigo's best win Donaire is better than Golovkin's best win which is Murray. I think that's pretty much a fact, don't see many people around who would claim otherwise. Now, compare the two men's hype either here or in the media and tell who is more overrated.
I'm not salty or anything because you said Rigo, I just arguing I think logically.