Middleweight Super Six Poll

[Jc8804]

Who wins it...........

GGG
end thread

[boliodogs]

Dirrell is a running, clinching, wrestling fighter with a weak chin and no heart. Froch beat him fair because he ran too much and held too much. He has some skill but not enough to be a champion. He was starting to come apart in the Abraham fight and Abraham would knock him out in a rematch. The Dirrell brothers will never be better than pretty good fighters.

[jackson8]

Dirrell is a running, clinching, wrestling fighter with a weak chin and no heart. Froch beat him fair because he ran too much and held too much. He has some skill but not enough to be a champion. He was starting to come apart in the Abraham fight and Abraham would knock him out in a rematch. The Dirrell brothers will never be better than pretty good fighters.

Rare to find someone that thinks Froch won that fight.

[FrankieClutch]

Damn good tourney. GGG or Canelo wins it

[juandabomb]

damn all of pueto lico voted on this one

[Dirk Diggler UK]

It's funny when you look at that list because people always say how horrible the division is when in reality it's really not. Golovkin or canelo takes it.

It's not really that good. Cotto isn't even a middleweight and is past his best. Quillin and Lee are on a similar level of averageness. Lemiuex is poor. Canelo is OK but not proven at middleweight. Hasn't even really made himself stand out from the crowd at 154.

[johnm is...]

U can say that in hindsight sure. But when the super six was finalized, Ward was considered the least likely to win it. U guys are being extremely revisionist right now. And SMW was much deeper than even that. U had Bute, Bika, Johnson etc right under those guys. It was a extremely packed division in those years. Nothing like middleweight is now.

Ward was the 2nd favorite (based on odds) to win the Super 6. He was a narrow underdog to Kessler/AA (who were about even).

[UNBIASED BOXING]

It's not really that good. Cotto isn't even a middleweight and is past his best. Quillin and Lee are on a similar level of averageness. Lemiuex is poor. Canelo is OK but not proven at middleweight. Hasn't even really made himself stand out from the crowd at 154.

So? You could say that same thing about almost all the divisions in boxing.

What division is considered, "strong", besides Welterweight?


also, lol @ the results. Canelo or Golovkin would win--- anyone with a brain/ability to think logically knows this.

[Chrismart]

I like it. That would be a good tournament IMO. I'd take Golovkin to win...there's some good fights to be made between those fighters on the list.

[BigAlexSand]

Cotto shouldn't be in the list... Should be substituted with Jacobs. I believe Golovkin, Canelo and Jacobs would come out with the best wins. Jacobs is often over looked, he is talented, Strong, Fast, Throws Good Combinations and Has a good Ring IQ. Personally I would take Jacobs in a fight against Lee,Quillin, Cotto and Lemieux.