Originally posted by HEND
View Post
1. Analogy between Cotto and GGG is not really valid. Nobody called Cotto to fight GGG, when Cotto was at 154. Now the fight is demanded only because Cotto has 160 belt and he is not willing to fight the mandatory. Not only that but he is not willing to fight at 160 at all (he fights at CWs). All of that is fine, but DROP the belt and do whatever you want.
Nobody should disrespect Floyd. He has no business at 160 and he doesn't need to give GGG shot at 154. If he does all kudos in the world!
2. Fighting Chavez or Froch is not 'going to 168' per se. Yes, he would fight those fights at 168, get LOADS of money and GO BACK to 160 probably unbeaten. Ward doesn't bring that money. Ward is a much harder fight. Ward is not even a star he was 3 years ago. So why give it ALL to fight Ward. You loose a lot if you get beaten, you get some (not as much as you should) if you beat Ward.
So in that view 164 is not unreasonable. It is a middle ground. In 1-2 years, after Ward (hopefully) cleans 168 again (DeGale, Direll..) and becomes verge of PPV, then YES - it should be 168.
3. Sure. Hagler generation was probably deeper. But don't forget that Duran fought Hagler and what is Duran's natural weight.. Every fighter should fight at his natural weight as long as they can accomplish something at that weight. Gennady still has a LOT to do at 160..
Comment