Keith Thurman vs Kell Brook who takes it?

[Redd Foxx]

Though Thurman still has some serious holes in his game and Brook is the more complete fighter, I think Thurman's offense is too strong for him. Kel's defense is good but he doesn't work off the back foot enough to win against Thurman. I just don't see how Brook scores enough points here without putting himself at great risk.

[JakeTheBoxer]

They won“t fight soon. After Floyd and Manny retire, Brook and Thurman will try to take over the division in separate ways.

[Beercules]

They won“t fight soon. After Floyd and Manny retire, Brook and Thurman will try to take over the division in separate ways.

I really do wonder who will be the man at WW when Floyd and Manny are gone. Hmmm


Obviously Floyd is the man at WW now.

[brettWall]

People need to stop mentioning this fight. It's clear they not going to fight any time soon. They'll avoid each other. It's obvious.

[Psylence83]

Thurman!!! I don't think we have seen the best in him yet

[RichCCFC]

Lets break it down

Strength - Brook, strongest 147 lber in the world
Power - Thurman, great puncher.. but Brook is also very heavy handed
Speed - Thurman .. again just about. Brook has quickness.
Defence - Brook, Thurman gets too wild in there and leaves himself wide open
Skills - Brook. He's the much better technical fighter by far with a much better jab.

How does it go? I see Brook being in control for the majority of the fight, style wise it could be similar to a mini Kitschko - Haye (only with obvious more drama), with Thurman trying to leap in and do damage and then circle the ring. I see Brook winning this one guys. He's just the better boxer and has more intangibles. I honestly think Brook is better inside and at mid range, Thurman may only have an advantage way on the outside.

[MPX309]

I'm going with my boy Kell, but I think it's pickem fight, and I'd be happy with whoever wins.

[IR0NFIST]

All Thurman has to do is land "one time", if Senchenko's right hand was strong enough to make Brook do a little dance, there's no doubt in my mind that Thurman is capable of doing the same; and then some.

[Sparked_26]

Brook looks great but the criticism of his resume is fair.

Brandon Rios would still be one of the best fighters he has faced and people see that is a mismatch.

[RichCCFC]

All Thurman has to do is land "one time", if Senchenko's right hand was strong enough to make Brook do a little dance, there's no doubt in my mind that Thurman is capable of doing the same; and then some.

why couldn't Porter then? you don't think he'd be more turned on and raise his level vs likes of Porter and Thurman?

Chaves gave Thurman hell!