Keith Thurman vs Kell Brook who takes it?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Thurman, I think his movement won't allow Brook to get positioned, I think Thurman will utilize feints to lure Brook in as well. It's one of those fights that will remain somewhat competitive until Thurman catches him with a right hook around the guard and shakes him up.

[Ringlife]

This is one of those fights that has to be made, and is one of the best match ups in the 147 division . This is to close to call, I did vote for Thurman by decision in a very close fight. If this fight does happen I would root for Brook, I like his style of fighting.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

If boxing was an actual organized, structured sport, these 2 should be fighting in an eliminator for floyd


I think it's a great fight and too close to tell...

[KayDub]

Right now this is THE fight to be made at 147lbs. These two are honestly #1 and #2 in the division, they just need to fight to decide who is actually #1.

I'm going with Thurman in this matchup, but it's really a 50/50 fight at the moment.

[nacho daddy]

both are scared of each other and will not fight until MAYBE one or both become paper champ

[al-Xander]

That's why I was saying Bundu would have been a tolerable fight for Brook, instead of Gavin. We could have had a sense how each fighter did with a common opponent. Brook took the loser in the Bundu/Gavin fight, instead of the winner. The Gavin fight was an absolute joke for this hypejob.

[FrankieBruno]

Thurman has wins over: The Ghost, Julio Diaz (draw with Porter), Jesus Soto Karass, Diego Gabriel Chaves, Leonard Bundu (destroyed Frankie Gavin)

Brook has : Porter

Brook had a very close win against a overrated Porter, with many people saying it was a draw, although i had Kell winning by 2 rounds.


You'd have to honestly favor Thurman

Brook is still unknown, we have only seen him in the ring with one style of boxer at a high level.

[sicko]

50/50 that is a tough one to call

[PivotandRoll]

Thurman has wins over: The Ghost, Julio Diaz (draw with Porter), Jesus Soto Karass, Diego Gabriel Chaves, Leonard Bundu (destroyed Frankie Gavin)

Brook has : Porter

Brook had a very close win against a overrated Porter, with many people saying it was a draw, although i had Kell winning by 2 rounds.


You'd have to honestly favor Thurman

Brook is still unknown, we have only seen him in the ring with one style of boxer at a high level.

Bundu destroyed Gavin?? How is a split decision a destruction?

[FrankieBruno]

Bundu destroyed Gavin?? How is a split decision a destruction?

I had it a UD

Gavin shud have also lost to Skeet, lucky to get the nod in that fight

Regardless my point still stands as far as Thurman fighting a number of different styles.

Thus far we know more about Thurman than we do about Brook.