Is Marcos Maidana a future hall-of-famer?

[shenmue]

i dunno but I think he deserves it. The amount of wars and KO's hes provided fans and has beaten a good number of good opponents

Yes, for entertainment purposes he does, like if there was an entertainment/warrior section he would be in for sure. As of right now its hard to say he should be in.

If he wins another title, beats a few more names then there would be an argument for him anyway, lets see what happens, good career anyway and a really fun fighter for the last 6 or 7 years. The Devon performance always makes him look bad for me, its his only really bad loss.

[soul_survivor]

Has 2-time world champion Marcos "El Chino" Maidana done enough in the ring to be inducted into the boxing hall of fame?

I think, yes, he has. Vote and discuss.

hell no...well back when the HOF stood for something, now anyone gets in, even a guy who has lost every major fight in his career.

[Mike D]

The HOF should be reserved for GREAT careers. Marcos has had himself a nice career, a career he should be very proud of, but it's not and shouldn't be hall of fame worthy. And not even close, to be honest.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Just the other day I was thinking about how much I missed watching Maidana fight, his fights are fun to watch, from fouling, making it into a street fight, ref involvement but his fans though, holy shit....

[Mike D]

I think Maidana can get into the HoF. All he has to do is buy an admission ticket and he can see quality boxers.

**** had me rolling

[IFightDirty]

If he would have beat Floyd and add in another signature win maybe against someone like Pacquiao, Marquez or move up to 154 against Canelo then maybe. Outside of a past prime Morales, Chino doesn't have a HOF type of win on his resume.

[LacedUp]

his best wins are ortiz, morales, and broner. think he needs a few more quality wins to get in but oh why the hell not, the IBHOF is a joke anyway.


the petrov fight was for a world title. maidana is a two-time world champion.

How could it be for a World title when Khan was WBA champ?

Seriously...

Maidana HOF

[LacedUp]

He's better than Gatti so yea.

This is apparently the new standard for HOF amongst rookie fans.

[Hype job]

Maidana is the gatekeeper for guys who need to know if they're elite...

Ortiz and Broner were both hyped and he put them on twerk street making them re-evaluate their careers.

[Dr Rumack]

Only in our hearts.