Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Pound-for-Pound Update

[Real Talk85]

Please explain how kovalev and GGG are on the list with the weak resumes they have. Look at their credentials by far they have the weakest competition.

so walking through a series of mismatches gets you on this list now? Froch should have their spots he has fought far better than either. Danny Garcia has faced all but two top 140 lbs fighters why is he not on the list At their spots but GGG and kovalev who outside of Pascal hasn't fought anyone to merit that spot.

Hopkins with what he was doing at his old age wasn't even up there Wtf.

[RawDawgHasSpokn]

Bradley just ruined my entire day.

[St. Johns Gent]

what kind of bull crap list is this?? blasphemy! the entire list! Crawford is rated higher than Danny but Crawford has one belt in the 140, GGG fights nothing but FNF fighters hell Santa Cruz has beaten way better opposition than triple fraud, Bradley??? seriously, and Chocolatito over Estrada, who has faced the tougher opposition hands down and is the only unified champ in that division??? and to include the fraud with the shoulder injury is a joke, whoever the writer is needs to get off the hype HBO purposely creates by orchestrating mismatches like Canelo vs Churchland (Church=Kirk=Circe=sorceress that'll turn you into a pig with power of illusion and devour your soul just like church), GGG vs Boxcino, Chocolate vs guy with a broken face years ago

1. Floyd TBE
2. Klitschko Domination
3. Rigo untouchable
4. Danny lineal, undisputed since 2012
5. Kovalev 3 belts in that weight
6. Estrada cleaned out that division
7. Loma Skills beyond words
8. Crawford handily beaten good fighters
9. Chocolatito
10. Andy Lee fights the best at 160, fights all the monsters, not some 6 ko boxcino champ

[Weebler I]

I still think there's a clear top 4 in Mayweather, Rigo, Gonzalez, and Pac. Assuming Ward is still Ward, it is a clear top 5. Other than that, the p4p list could go in so many directions. Kovalev should definitely be there somewhere. Just off potential, I'd think Golovkin and Crawford should as well.

Rigo's record in recent times consists of Kokietgym and Amagasa. It's not exactly top 4 PFP competition. Agbeko back in 2013 was a lower top 10 guy.

Granted, it's not his fault but still, I don't think he's a lock in the top 4.

One of the problems with these lists is it means different things to different people, but for me a fighter has to keep fighting and beating top contenders to retain their spot or else they begin to drop down.

[-PBP-]

This is hard. My list changes every day.

1. Mayweather
2. Wlad
3. Chocolotito
4. Rigo
5. Kovalev
6. Pacquiao
7. Golovkin
8. Estrada
9. Crawford
10. Lomachenko

[MrTambourineMan]

Pros - No Ward, Marquez and CaneLOL

Cons - Bradley

[Cuban Linx]

The right guys are there but I'm not sure about the order.

[soul_survivor]

what the hell kinda list is this?

Gonzalez at number 2 over someone like wlad?

Pacquiao below kovalev?

I don't mind Kov in the top 5....but how is Rigo still so high?

How is Crawford number 10 over Canelo?

What's the criteria for this list?

[Weebler I]

What's the criteria for this list?

I don't think anyone has ever quite that worked out with any degree of consistent uniformity.

Some think it's a skills-based subjective selection, i.e. if everyone was the same size, who would win or who is the best? while others subjectively rate the resumes in boxing and base the list on achievement.

[daggum]

what kind of bull crap list is this?? blasphemy! the entire list! Crawford is rated higher than Danny but Crawford has one belt in the 140, GGG fights nothing but FNF fighters hell Santa Cruz has beaten way better opposition than triple fraud, Bradley??? seriously, and Chocolatito over Estrada, who has faced the tougher opposition hands down and is the only unified champ in that division??? and to include the fraud with the shoulder injury is a joke, whoever the writer is needs to get off the hype HBO purposely creates by orchestrating mismatches like Canelo vs Churchland (Church=Kirk=Circe=sorceress that'll turn you into a pig with power of illusion and devour your soul just like church), GGG vs Boxcino, Chocolate vs guy with a broken face years ago

1. Floyd TBE
2. Klitschko Domination
3. Rigo untouchable
4. Danny lineal, undisputed since 2012
5. Kovalev 3 belts in that weight
6. Estrada cleaned out that division
7. Loma Skills beyond words
8. Crawford handily beaten good fighters
9. Chocolatito
10. Andy Lee fights the best at 160, fights all the monsters, not some 6 ko boxcino champ

ggg tried to fight chavez jr and quillin and they rejected his offers. you do know this right? so these "monsters" didn't want any part of ggg