Is it safe to say that no version of Pac beats Mayweather?

[-Kev-]

This was Pacquiao's best chance.

[jjbj2]

The knockout that Marquez gave Pacman showed first in the Bradley fight then absolutely in Mayweather fight. PTSD or some thing.

I really think the 2007 or 2010 Manny version could have been a Mayweather vs Maidana I competitive but still a Mayweather win. Oh well, Manny is still my favorite fighter.

I guess Mayweather's TBE is legit now. F U C K! I'm still salty with Pacman not throwing caution out of the window.

[betmen]

yes, mayweather will never lose againts smaller man

[Sugar Adam Ali]

2009-10 manny would have his best chance

[-Kev-]

5 yrs ago Manny's better energy would have forced Floyd to engage more, and it would have been more like Mayweather-Maidana I than it turned out to be.

Floyd still wins, but a more competitive fight.

May-Pac would never be like Mayweather-Maidana because first of all Pacquiao is not 160lbs, and secondly Pacquiao does not like the rough stuff and fouling like Maidana. No way in hell any version of Pac bullies Mayweather. That's just not what he does and no matter how many times fans say that Pac could give a similar performance like Maidana, it will never be true. It's not his style, he does not have the size to pull it off. You people need to stop with the Maidana talk in regards to Pacquiao.

[Slick_Rick]

Pre Marquez KO would have outworked Floyd.

I dont understand why people are getting so hung up on some sort of schooling or total dominance, there were a lot of close rounds which Floyd nicked from a few single shots, a little more emphasis from Manny and he would have taken them.
People should re watch the Marquez fight to see how much more daring Manny was, and his willingness to take one to get one, he was much more nimble as well and that was not even his prime.

[Southpaw93]

2009/2010 manny would of KOd him

[Ahmed_Ismail]

No it's not. Pac has a shot chin and had an injured shoulder.

Since the KO he's been tentative, he would have thrown caution to the wind in 2010.

Shot chin after the KO? what about before the KO? knocked out at 106 and 112, knocked down by a jab at 112, knocked down by a nobody at 126, seriously hurt against Morales and Marquez at 130 lbs?

Woulda thrown caution to the wind in 2010? Maybe, but he woulda got countered much more and remember, Floyd was younger, fresher and much better at 2010, if you look at Floyd' performance against Maidana last year and his Performance against Marquez or Mosley in 2010, you can see a HUGE difference, although Floyd wasn't active at all at 20009 2010. he was still sharper, quicker and threw with more conviction than now even though he's more active now, and still he gave Pacquiao a boxing lesson, Pacquiao was the one coming off an impressive win against Algieri (who ain't **** anyways but ok) and a good win against Bradley who's a top welterweight, Pacquiao looked better than Floyd in 2014 and the old version of Floyd gave Pacquiao a boxing lesson, don't see how a younger version of Floyd couldn't have done the same!

[Street]

I voted 2004 Pac version but I take it back because Mayweather was also quicker. Therefore, no version of Pac ever beats a Mayweather of the same period.

[Southpaw93]

Shot chin after the KO? what about before the KO? knocked out at 106 and 112, knocked down by a jab at 112, knocked down by a nobody at 126, seriously hurt against Morales and Marquez at 130 lbs?

Woulda thrown caution to the wind in 2010? Maybe, but he woulda got countered much more and remember, Floyd was younger, fresher and much better at 2010, if you look at Floyd' performance against Maidana last year and his Performance against Marquez or Mosley in 2010, you can see a HUGE difference, although Floyd wasn't active at all at 20009 2010. he was still sharper, quicker and threw with more conviction than now even though he's more active now, and still he gave Pacquiao a boxing lesson, Pacquiao was the one coming off an impressive win against Algieri (who ain't **** anyways but ok) and a good win against Bradley who's a top welterweight, Pacquiao looked better than Floyd in 2014 and the old version of Floyd gave Pacquiao a boxing lesson, don't see how a younger version of Floyd couldn't have done the same!

The pacquiao that fought cotto, hatton, clottey, would of beaten floyd who fought mosley. Mosley was 38 years old and almost KOd him lol