Can you even call these guys elite level talent?

[Mike D]

The chin isn't the issue. The issue is that he doesn't know how to hide it. He doesn't know how to use his attributes/abilities, etc etc.

Hitman and Wlad "made it" with chin issues.

Good points.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Brook had a bloody nose where he could barely breathe...?

What happened in the rematch? What ended up happening to Senchenko ultimately? Maybe those guys on the list can hurt and put leather on Brook too but will they be able to beat him?

Porter was much better than those "guys" who put leather on Brook and what happened to Brook?

The rematch was a 10 rounder, at a catch weight, this forced Jones to take more of an initiative. That performance in the rematch doesn't excuse the fact that Brook's chin and ability to recover is questionable. Also, I'm not sure Brook is gonna be able to make the weight healthy, Brook is stocky, too many question marks with Brook.

[Chiboxing123]

Would honestly put Kell Brook ahead of these guys, talent wise.
You can argue that these guys are world class, as they clearly had the dedication and talent to get this far, holding belts re re. However what people fail to understand that at the elite level, there are several levels. Few elite boxers today are may, pac, andre ward, rigondeaux re re

To add to that elite I say ggg,wlad and kovalev. Those euros are though....but yeah kell brook beats everybody on that list besides bradley and thurman.