How high of an ATG would manny be if beat Mayweather?

[BOXEO _]

You guys are crazy.
Both arent top 25 no matter what they do.

Hahaha, hard cold truth right there.



Too bad this fight didn't happen 5-6 years ago.
.

[RetroSpeed05]

I think he should be up there, 8 weight division champ and if he beats Floyd he would be the first 5 time lineal champ. Which is crazy in 8 weight divisions he would be the man and the true champ in 5 of those.

[Godsfly]

Top 3 with Ali and SRR

greater then fighters like reberto duran?


muhahaha

[VERDUGO]

He will be TBE OTB...The Best Ever Of The Bestest....

[IronDanHamza]

Very high.

His resume would be insane with Mayweather on it.

[The Viper]

Very high.

His resume would be insane with Mayweather on it.

This.................

[5.4ever]

I'm no nuthugger but I admit, manny is my fav boxer since Roy jones.

That being said, a clear dominating win over floyd would put him in the top 25, at best...

His career has been marvelous and he's done so much for the sport of boxing, but no way does that make him top 10, much less top 3. People who say that don't know boxing or boxers in history too well...

If floyd beats manny very clearly, and goes on to fight two of the bigger names in boxing and beats them also and retires a perfect 50, that would put him In the top 25 for sure...


I dislike floyd but can still salvage some of his legacy with what he does in the next three fights...

[TMTForever]

greater then fighters like reberto duran?


muhahaha

you mean roberto "no mas" duran great in your mind no mas in so many others!

[Strategic1]

In overall boxing ability top 20 perhaps.
But in terms of a boxer's story/uniqueness,... top 5 or top 3. Heck you can argue #1 in story.

overcome poverty, hustled on the streets of Manila, 8 division champ, lineal in 5 divisions, comeback from several knockout defeats, and to defeat one of the greatest defensive fighters ever...

That's one heck of a story. And would be legendary.

[HanzGruber]

Top 10 for beating a 38 yr old Floyd? Surely you jest