Why doesn't PAC's win over Rios get as much as Floyd's over Guerrero's?!?

[torosboxing75]

Rios and The Ghost are a Level apart but similar in style. RG is a B-/B+ fighter and Rios is a C Level fighter. What Manny did against Rios was very impressive. Why? Because he was coming off of a controversial KO. He showed he still had the heart, speed, stamina, and will to win. If had got old that night, he would've taken a beating. Rios has power and is relentless. RG is more of a boxer but still in the plodder zone. He wants to come forward and ****. I wasn't impressed with Floyd's win over him because he shouldn't have gotten that fight anyway. When you're on top, you must continue to take the challenging fights. RG was hardly a challenge for Floyd. If Rios and The Ghost fight, it would be a WAR. Who would win? The Ghost would win because he is faster and can do a little more in the ring.

I never heard of a controversial KO.

[GOD-FR33]

I know. I know.

I never heard of a controversial KO.

I know. I know. Anyone with common sense knows Roidquez is on the juice. Why do you think his knee got hurt and he wasn't even training seriously. Smh.

[ADP02]

Big difference between Mayweather/ Thurman and Chaves /Alvarado. Please.

Well here is the problem.
If you want to discount Chaves/Alvarado then why don't we just discount Guerrero? Chavez and Guerrero are pretty much ranked the same and Guerrero lost most recently while Chavez had a draw against a top rated P4P fighter.




.

[HeroBando]

Berto was top 10. Aydin.was ranked higher than anybody Rios has beaten at 147. Both were for that matter.

No he wasnt. Remember he was suspended for PEDs and out for over a year. Aydin is a bum and tiny at welter. Guerrero did worse against him than Jojo Dan in their first matchup, in freaking Turkey

[Hype job]

I had him up by 3, I excluded all point deductions from both sides. Chaves was in control of the fight and was winning the round he got disqualified as well.

I wasn't comparing the fight, I was comparing the form of defeat (getting disqualified while up on the cards).

You're not a pro judge so who cares.

Rios beats Guerrero.

[Johnwoo8686]

pathetic lies. rios wasn't coming off a loss at lightweight. he fought twice a jr welterweight before fighting pac.

and that one loss was against a guy he destroyed in the first and then destroyed again in the rubber match.

He was coming off a loss at SUPER lightweight. Are you happy now? A guy who spent most of his career at light weight and never fought at welterweight, who was also coming off a loss is somehow better than a guy who's had several fights at welterweight and was coming off a win?

Guerrero > Rios

[solo20]

He was coming off a loss at SUPER lightweight. Are you happy now? A guy who spent most of his career at light weight and never fought at welterweight, who was also coming off a loss is somehow better than a guy who's had several fights at welterweight and was coming off a win?

Guerrero > Rios

BOTH ARE GARBAGE ---->Guerrero > Rios<---BOTH ARE GARBAGE


CRAP IS STILL CRAP NO MATTER WHAT BOTH STINK IN IN THE END

LAUGHING AT THE GUYS TRYING TO MAKE A CASE ON HOW GOOD THESE FIGHTERS ARE WAHAHA

[ironmt]

After Pacquiao beat Rios, Rios was a bum. After Rios beat Alvarado In there third fight he became a pound for pound fighter that has a legitimate chance of beating anyone In his division Including Mayweather.

Anyone that has been around this forum any length of time understands that It Is very difficult to take this place seriously and actually discuss boxing In an unbiased manner.

[joseph5620]

Well here is the problem.
If you want to discount Chaves/Alvarado then why don't we just discount Guerrero? Chavez and Guerrero are pretty much ranked the same and Guerrero lost most recently while Chavez had a draw against a top rated P4P fighter.

I don't even understand your point here as it has nothing to do with my statements. You pointed out that Guerrero was 3-2 at welterweight. Those two losses were to Mayweather and Thurman which is far more respectable than losing to Alvarado.

Again what does Chaves rating have to do with this? The topic is Rios who has done absolutely nothing at 147 and far less than Guerrero which I pointed out the first time.



.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Because rios had been on the slide getting a gift vs Abril, and beaten by Alvarado in the rematch.. Ghost was on a nice win streak and has been around much longer than rios and has multiple weight class paper titles