higher alltime oscar or cotto?

[Bardock]

He lost to Shane and Cotto won, that gives it to Cotto, sorry. Mayorga is **** are you kidding me? Cotto KO'd him too, saying he struggled is grasping, he lost 2 rounds on all the scorecards and ended up KO'ing him anyway. So far the only name worth mentioned is Pernell Whitaker and he was more past it than Martinez when they fought, but MUCH MUCH smaller than Oscar.

So your defense that Oscar is better is because he lost twice to a guy Cotto beat. He beat a crappy fighter by KO, the same guy Cotto KO'd, a loss to Tito is a good thing... apparently.

With logic like that no wonder you guys think Oscar is better.

Cotto lost to Margarito with bricks, Manny by draining. Oscar asked to fight Manny at 147, so that's not his fault. See... how dumb your thinking is.

Overall... it's close, but one guys career isn't over which is why I never voted. After Cotto gets done with Canelo and Mayweather you'll come around, but he really is slightly already ahead of him already.

[Beater_of_ass]

of course not, cotto is better cuz he beated mosley doe...

Against common opponents, Cotto's winning. Period.

[Mitchell Kane]

Pernell Whitaker and he was more past it than Martinez when they fought

But his legs still worked.

[Beater_of_ass]

Big Baby is licking his chops just like Cotto, he knows what's coming.

[El-blanco]

He lost to Shane and Cotto won, that gives it to Cotto, sorry. Mayorga is **** are you kidding me? Cotto KO'd him too, saying he struggled is grasping, he lost 2 rounds on all the scorecards and ended up KO'ing him anyway. So far the only name worth mentioned is Pernell Whitaker and he was more past it than Martinez when they fought, but MUCH MUCH smaller than Oscar.

So your defense that Oscar is better is because he lost twice to a guy Cotto beat. He beat a crappy fighter by KO, the same guy Cotto KO'd, a loss to Tito is a good thing... apparently.

With logic like that no wonder you guys think Oscar is better.

Cotto lost to Margarito with bricks, Manny by draining. Oscar asked to fight Manny at 147, so that's not his fault. See... how dumb your thinking is.

Overall... it's close, but one guys career isn't over which is why I never voted. After Cotto gets done with Canelo and Mayweather you'll come around, but he really is slightly already ahead of him already.

Oscar would have never been beat by a guy like trout, never. He's not as good as him man, watch him fight. The fact that you discredit oscars resume tells me you're young or unbelievably biased. I'm a cotto fan, but I'm also objective. You keep bringing up the Shane fight as if it was the same guy. Go watch those fights again.

[Beater_of_ass]

But his legs still worked.

So did Martinez... he even ran across the ring. Did you watch the fight?

[icha]

Against common opponents, Cotto's winning. Period.

so canelo better than cotto since he beated trout.. period.

[Beater_of_ass]

Oscar would have never been beat by a guy like trout, never. He's not as good as him man, watch him fight. The fact that you discredit oscars resume tells me you're young or unbelievably biased. I'm a cotto fan, but I'm also objective.

Cotto has a bad loss where did I say he didn't? Oscar has 2 KO losses before the 10th round, Cotto wouldn't ever let that happen.

[Beater_of_ass]

so canelo better than cotto since he beated trout.. period.

Nah, Canelo's performance against Floyd ruined any credibilty he had with that win. Cotto's won more rounds between the two of them. So... Cotto's still winning.

[El-blanco]

Cotto has a bad loss where did I say he didn't? Oscar has 2 KO losses before the 10th round, Cotto wouldn't ever let that happen.

You're right, he'd just run around the ring taking knees until the ref stops the fight.