higher alltime oscar or cotto?

[El-blanco]

Yes Oscar did win a mw title..whats Cotto's best wins?

This guy is like twenty he's never seen oscar fight.

[Larry the boss]

I mean i like Cotto...but Oscar clearly had the better career....

[Larry the boss]

This guy is like twenty he's never seen oscar fight.

The man actually said Oscar never won a MW title..and then asked who he beat like Cotto has great wins or something

[El-blanco]

The man actually said Oscar never won a MW title..and then asked who he beat like Cotto has great wins or something

He also compared oscars performance against Floyd to the disgraceful effort by canelo. Another thread he said cotto is top 3 of the era.

[Jc8804]

These cotto fans are newbies


Quartey was a beast
vargas was a tough out
mosley fights were 50 50 in prime plus roids
whitaker is ATG ,past it he was still a B+ fighter with intellegence and skill.like fighting toney.

B hop was a hill to climb
sturm is and was very solid and durable.
floyd was prime and had his hands full
tito was outclassed
mayorga was a tough out.
chavez ---see whitaker
Oscar was a real fighter.. he is an ATG.fought the best at their best
cotto is a contemporary great turned hall of famer.

People forget oscar became a part timer.
All oscars loses were past prime as a part timer.

Prime ,you can argue whitaker ..i had a draw.


Oscar by miles

H2H innprime oscar vs cotto. Cotto gets stopped inside of 9 rds at 160 154 or 147 and 140..
oscar would own him.

[BIG GUNZ]

Oscar easily. Oscar has way better wins. And a few of his losses were pure robberies. He really should only have 3 or 4 losses. Cotto has some good wins, but Oscar has the better overall resume.

[Jc8804]

On top of that,oscar didnt belong at 160. Pudgy slow and he topped out imo at 154.

147 vs tito a better rican witha better career then cotto as well.oscar outclassed him..

Prime oscar beats prime floyd imo.shane cheated.vs pac he was draimed and past it obviously..looked like a drained c minus fighter. No better then chris algeiri that night.

5 loses are garbage really. Floyd beat a part time past it oscar fighting at b minus level imo.but it counts..other 5 losses dont define him ...

Oscar was a bad man.

[Dr Rumack]

Didn't think the poll would be one-sided. Oscar for me too.

[Beater_of_ass]

The man actually said Oscar never won a MW title..and then asked who he beat like Cotto has great wins or something

No I was just specifically thinking about the Hopkins fight. Sorry that I forgot someone's fights that happend 10-15 years ago. I do have other things to worry about, I'm not unemployed.

[Fantasiabruja]

Cotto is my favorite fighter but Oscar has accomplished a whole lot more, and has fought the better competition.