higher alltime oscar or cotto?

[Spray_resistant]

Oscar beat roided shane
cotto beat past it shane

The result of one common opponent faced means little when comparing entire careers.

Pac made Oscar quit on his stool three quarters the way through the fight Cotto lasted until the 12th, probably could have survived the round if Bayless didn't save Cotto from more punishment.......doesn't mean much does it?

[f15bone]

I would favor DLH....

Especially if u take ALL factors into account....

[ironmike2012]

Oscar by a mile. Cotto is okay, but Oscar was great.

[Baltimore]

The Golden Boy for sure

[Build That Wall]

Oscar, and it is not even close.


Cotto isn't even worthy enough to hold Oscars Jockstrap, But Oscar would want him too and Cotto would gladly hold it for him.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Cotto is in a tough spot because the opponents we want to see him in against, the majority would favor them against Cotto. Not sure he'll be able to enhance his legacy any further from the looks of it.

It's Oscar obviously.

[Pugilist95]

Oscar, his resume is better than Mayweathers and arguably better than Pacquiao's as well.

[jas]

******ed question but I don't expect anything more from this poster

[Skip Bayless]

oscar easy

[Daddy T]

who are the two tards that said cotto?