higher alltime oscar or cotto?

[soul_survivor]

na Cotto, he is the greatest of all time cripple mauler

[No bueno]

Gotta go with East L.A 's golden boy on this one . Oscar fought the best competition win or lose . And that Gold Medal . Not even close .

[bigjavi973]

ODH hands down. The hate on cotto is real that someone has to make a meaningless thread such as this.

[Mr. 29K]

Cotto??? Are you serious??? Go kill yourself for even typing this.

[sapaw]

Not even close!

[Beater_of_ass]

ODLH any way you look at it. And he would have diced Cotto up if they ever did it prime for prime.

No he woudn't have... LMAO. Who did Oscar beat... Old Chavez and Ike Quartey, those are literally his best wins. Oscar ducked the **** out of Cotto after the Mosley fight, it's even on youtube. The announcer said I asked Oscar if he wants to you fight you and Oscar said "No."

Really, that's all you need to know. Cotto has the better resume in terms of victories, Oscar won more belts in more weight divisions. Also, Oscar winning gold means what exactly? Cotto won silver I believe at the 2000 Olympics, it's not THAT big of a difference.

[MrP4P]

Its not as "easy" as others try to point out. Oscar is known for fighting EVERYONE in his era, but so has Cotto.. Oscar's early career success gives him the edge IMO but Oscar has also lost nearly all of his biggest fights, and that matters. Cotto winning the lineal Middleweight championship makes this a legit conversation to be had however. Head 2 Head I think Cotto will always be seen as the favorite... especially post Trinidad Oscar, He NEVER liked body shots, Im not even talking about the digusting Hopkins fight either, and Cotto is money with his liver shot.

[PeasantCrusha]

Oscar had that style...Speed and power... it's hard not to appreciate what Oscar brought to the table. His win over a "shop worn" Chavez... Eh. I would not put Cotto too far behind Oscar.

[PR ESQ.]

Cotto without doubt will share space in Canastota with the Golden boy in the near future but Oscar's career is superior to Cotto's.

[ramses07]

No he woudn't have... LMAO. Who did Oscar beat... Old Chavez and Ike Quartey, those are literally his best wins. Oscar ducked the **** out of Cotto after the Mosley fight, it's even on youtube. The announcer said I asked Oscar if he wants to you fight you and Oscar said "No."

Really, that's all you need to know. Cotto has the better resume in terms of victories, Oscar won more belts in more weight divisions. Also, Oscar winning gold means what exactly? Cotto won silver I believe at the 2000 Olympics, it's not THAT big of a difference.

LOL cotto won a silver medal at the central american and carribean games lol wtf

oscar won a gold medal at the olympics