Mayorga vs Margario at 147 who wins?

[T Magee]

Antonio Margarito was one of the greatest welterweights of the last decade.

Mayorga was an over-hyped brawler.

[IronDanHamza]

I'm not overrating anything... Name another welterweight in the last 20 years that has as much single shot power as mayorga does besides Tito and that Mexican dude that lost to james page, I forget his name..

Since 2000 mayorga is the hardest puncher at welter, and I really can't think of anyone that has one punch power that's even comparable at welter

So I don't think I'm overrating his power

Where's this one punch power coming from? Who has he knocked out with one punch?

Mayorga is not even that hard of a puncher to be honest let alone some massive puncher you're making him out to be.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Both Pacquaio, Cotto and Shane are.

Mayorga is not stopping Margarito early. That is never going to happen.

Shane stopped margs, because margs came head first in, repeatedly and had no backup plan.. If shane and ricardo both hit very hard, then one can assume that mayorga could hurt and stop tony...

cotto and manny are both superior skilled but i dont think they hit as hard with one punch, more of accumulation of punches, especially at welter for manny.. Cotto does have some pop, but he is more like a chavez sr where all the punches are stiff but not one hit stoppers

[IronDanHamza]

Shane stopped margs, because margs came head first in, repeatedly and had no backup plan.. If shane and ricardo both hit very hard, then one can assume that mayorga could hurt and stop tony...

cotto and manny are both superior skilled but i dont think they hit as hard with one punch, more of accumulation of punches, especially at welter for manny.. Cotto does have some pop, but he is more like a chavez sr where all the punches are stiff but not one hit stoppers

Shane stopped Margarito because he had the perfect style to do so.

I never disputed Mayorga could hurt Margarito but he's definitely not stopping him early.

Mayorga isn't a "one hit stopper".

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Antonio Margarito was one of the greatest welterweights of the last decade.

Mayorga was an over-hyped brawler.

SMH... margs had a good run at welter but him and ricardo arent welter greats...

Where's this one punch power coming from? Who has he knocked out with one punch?

Mayorga is not even that hard of a puncher to be honest let alone some massive puncher you're making him out to be.

Who hits harder since 2000 at welter??.. outside of tito and lopez you would have to go back to the 80s to find welters that could **** with one punch like mayorga...

Mayorga 00-03 was a beast of a puncher.. Even as an old shot fighter up in weight he gave shane and cotto hell for 12 rds, and both went on to become champs after..

[IronDanHamza]

SMH... margs had a good run at welter but him and ricardo arent welter greats...



Who hits harder since 2000 at welter??.. outside of tito and lopez you would have to go back to the 80s to find welters that could **** with one punch like mayorga...

Mayorga 00-03 was a beast of a puncher.. Even as an old shot fighter up in weight he gave shane and cotto hell for 12 rds, and both went on to become champs after..

There's not been many punchers in that time frame.

No you don't have to go back to the 80's.

He wasn't a "beast of a puncher" all these descriptions you keep coming out with are not true.

He didn't give Cotto hell he was dominated and knocked out by Cotto.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Shane stopped Margarito because he had the perfect style to do so.

I never disputed Mayorga could hurt Margarito but he's definitely not stopping him early.

Mayorga isn't a "one hit stopper".

What is this perfect style???

Margs comes forward, and shane has good power and wont get bullied.. Shane couldnt miss tony with anything.. It wasnt like shane was moving around like floyd or hopkins, doing the shoulder roll and picking his shots to counter.. Shane just let margs come to him, and he unloaded... Its suicide to walk head first repeatedly into a big puncher, especially one you cant bully..
Tony wouldnt be able to bully mayorga, would come head first the entire fight and mayorga would have a field day.. Margs has the one style to make mayorga look good...

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Stop trolling man

Mayorga couldn't do half of what Mosley did that night. They are completely different fighters.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

There's not been many punchers in that time frame.

No you don't have to go back to the 80's.

He wasn't a "beast of a puncher" all these descriptions you keep coming out with are not true.

He didn't give Cotto hell he was dominated and knocked out by Cotto.

You need to watch cotto-ricardo again...

old Mayorga gives hell to shane,,, next fight shane dominates champ margs

old mayorga gives hell to cotto,,, next fight cotto stops margs in rematch..

old semi retired mayorga did much better than champion margs with 2 common opponents in back to back fights...

Name guys that hit harder than mayorga at welter...

tito, lopez, prime oscar, prime shane, are about the only people.. thats about it.. 1990-2014, 25 years, an entire generation of fighters, only a handful of guys compare to mayorga's power...

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Stop trolling man

Mayorga couldn't do half of what Mosley did that night. They are completely different fighters.

What did mosley do that night??

He stood there, let tony come barreling in, and unloaded on him, rinse and repeat...There is no doubt that mayorga could do the same...

Lets not act like mosley put on some clinic like hopkins did tito..

Margs was one dimensional bully fighter, that had only one way to attack and no defense and was very predictable...Mayorga is about the same, but his strength of punching power is the great neutralizer to margs swarming tactics...