Comments Thread For: Mayweather Stays, Roman Rises: Pound for Pound Update

[IronDanHamza]

I think they are close in quality and Estrada is having a better year. IMO, Viloria and Matty are equally solid.

I be went back and forth on Ward, Rigo, and Roman. They're all special talents. Roman has been the best in three classes and his continued dominance won.

Don't see that at all.

Viloria is such an overrated fighter.

[crold1]

Why did Ward stay there?

He may yet resolve issues. Removed at year inactive.

[crold1]

Gonzalez is one of the best fighters in the world. Criminally underrated, even by so called boxing fans.

Changing rapidly

[bojangles1987]

Danny Garcia? Really?

Otherwise, I like it. I usually like Cliff Rold p4p lists. Lots of people who don't know anything about Gonzalez are going to whine. I suggest those people go watch his fights and learn about his opposition. Dude's legit.

I don't know about the 2 spot, that seems high, but with Ward dropping because of inactivity that spot is hard to fill. It's either Rigo, Pac, or Gonzalez IMO.

[LacedUp]

He may yet resolve issues. Removed at year inactive.

But I don't understand why everyone are moving around based on good years and bad years when Ward who hasn't fought in nearly a year, and not at all in 2014, is ranked #3.

And how come Klitschko is out? I mean, in the last 12 months he's still beaten #1 contender Povetkin and his mandatory. Someone like Danny Garcia in the last 12 months has struggled horribly with a mediocre guy in Herrera and fought the worst cherrypick since.. well since Klitschko fought Pianeta.

[LacedUp]

Danny Garcia? Really?

Otherwise, I like it. I usually like Cliff Rold p4p lists. Lots of people who don't know anything about Gonzalez are going to whine. I suggest those people go watch his fights and learn about his opposition. Dude's legit.

I don't know about the 2 spot, that seems high, but with Ward dropping because of inactivity that spot is hard to fill. It's either Rigo, Pac, or Gonzalez IMO.

It's Rigo, clearly.

[crold1]

But I don't understand why everyone are moving around based on good years and bad years when Ward who hasn't fought in nearly a year, and not at all in 2014, is ranked #3.

And how come Klitschko is out? I mean, in the last 12 months he's still beaten #1 contender Povetkin and his mandatory. Someone like Danny Garcia in the last 12 months has struggled horribly with a mediocre guy in Herrera and fought the worst cherrypick since.. well since Klitschko fought Pianeta.

I don't think Klits overall quality of comp warrants a rating. Great Heavyweight. Not great compared to the skill and depth of what guys in the best divisions have to deal with.

[IronDanHamza]

Danny Garcia? Really?

Otherwise, I like it. I usually like Cliff Rold p4p lists. Lots of people who don't know anything about Gonzalez are going to whine. I suggest those people go watch his fights and learn about his opposition. Dude's legit.

I don't know about the 2 spot, that seems high, but with Ward dropping because of inactivity that spot is hard to fill. It's either Rigo, Pac, or Gonzalez IMO.

Can see Gonzalez being in the lower half of the 10, there's no way he's #2.

And Estrada being in the Top 10 is outright crazy.

[nycsmooth]

2 me it doesn't matter after #4, call it p4p but nothing great there...I'd switch 3 & 4..DID YOU GUYS EVER HEAR OR SEE DONNIE NIETES?? Get w/it...

[SERGEY DRAGO]

Who are these men? I will krush their skulls like sparrow's egg!