Is Gennady Golovkin deserving of being in the top 10 P4P now?

[IMDAZED]

Not yet. Needs a signature win.

[The Big Dunn]

he has beaten plenty of good fighters but you won't recognize that because you are a hater filled with a lot of hate.

find peace with yourself and then come back to me because i get tired arguing with blind haters.

Here is his list of opponents. Show me where plenty of good ones are.

Daniel Geale TKO
Osumanu Adama TKO
Curtis Stevens TKO
Matthew Macklin] KO
Nobuhiro Ishida KO
Gabriel Rosado TKO
Grzegorz Proksa TKO
Makoto Fuchigami TKO
Lajuan Simon KO
Kassim Ouma TKO
Nilson Julio Tapia KO
Milton Nunez KO
Mikhail Makarov KO
John Anderson Carvalho KO
Anthony Greenidge KO
Javier Alberto Mamani TKO
Malik Dziarra RTD
Amar Amari UD
Ibrahim Sid TKO
Ian Gardner UD
Tshepo Mashego KO
Mehdi Bouadla UD
Sergei Khomitsky TKO
Simon Mokoena RTD
Sylvain Gomis KO
Jorge Ariel Garcia KO
Martins Kukulis TKO
Daniel Urbanski TKO
Sergei Navarka TKO
Gabor Balogh KO

[gmc_rfc_06]

I have him in the top 10.

Mayweather
Rigo

Those two are locked in, after that it's all hard to order.

Ward, Froch, Pac, Golovkin, Cotto....they are all in.

[Public_Enemy]

Here is his list of opponents. Show me where plenty of good ones are.

Daniel Geale TKO
Osumanu Adama TKO
Curtis Stevens TKO
Matthew Macklin] KO
Nobuhiro Ishida KO
Gabriel Rosado TKO
Grzegorz Proksa TKO
Makoto Fuchigami TKO
Lajuan Simon KO
Kassim Ouma TKO
Nilson Julio Tapia KO
Milton Nunez KO
Mikhail Makarov KO
John Anderson Carvalho KO
Anthony Greenidge KO
Javier Alberto Mamani TKO
Malik Dziarra RTD
Amar Amari UD
Ibrahim Sid TKO
Ian Gardner UD
Tshepo Mashego KO
Mehdi Bouadla UD
Sergei Khomitsky TKO
Simon Mokoena RTD
Sylvain Gomis KO
Jorge Ariel Garcia KO
Martins Kukulis TKO
Daniel Urbanski TKO
Sergei Navarka TKO
Gabor Balogh KO

I'm a fan of GGG but the hypocrisy is ridiculous. Remember when Macklin, Barker and Murray were crap wins for Martinez over domestic level fighters.

GGG is a rising star but people need to be more realistic when discussing his resume. The skills are apparent. Eventually his resume will coincide with his talents.

[King_]

Mayweather has recently fought several opponent who were no better (or perhaps worse) than Geale, who had never decisively lost before.

- Victor Ortiz who was KOed by old Collazo
- Robert Guerrero was good at featherweight but mediocre at welterweight
- Maidana lost to the better fighters he faced, yet was in a close fight with Floyd

Don't forget Canelo fought 40 Mcdonalds cashiers before fighting Trout and then getting a fight with Floyd and being called "The One"

[The Big Dunn]

Mayweather has recently fought several opponent who were no better (or perhaps worse) than Geale, who had never decisively lost before.

- Victor Ortiz who was KOed by old Collazo
- Robert Guerrero was good at featherweight but mediocre at welterweight
- Maidana lost to the better fighters he faced, yet was in a close fight with Floyd

Here is GGG's complete resume. No way he is top 10 p4p.

Daniel Geale TKO
Osumanu Adama TKO
Curtis Stevens TKO
Matthew Macklin] KO
Nobuhiro Ishida KO
Gabriel Rosado TKO
Grzegorz Proksa TKO
Makoto Fuchigami TKO
Lajuan Simon KO
Kassim Ouma TKO
Nilson Julio Tapia KO
Milton Nunez KO
Mikhail Makarov KO
John Anderson Carvalho KO
Anthony Greenidge KO
Javier Alberto Mamani TKO
Malik Dziarra RTD
Amar Amari UD
Ibrahim Sid TKO
Ian Gardner UD
Tshepo Mashego KO
Mehdi Bouadla UD
Sergei Khomitsky TKO
Simon Mokoena RTD
Sylvain Gomis KO
Jorge Ariel Garcia KO
Martins Kukulis TKO
Daniel Urbanski TKO
Sergei Navarka TKO
Gabor Balogh KO

[The Big Dunn]

Don't forget Canelo fought 40 Mcdonalds cashiers before fighting Trout and then getting a fight with Floyd and being called "The One"

This is where all posters who say GGG is top 10 p4p are exposing themselves. Canelo's resume is same, maybe slightly better when he fought Floyd, and all of you, as did I, say he wasn't top 10.

Fine. Explain how GGG is. I posted his resume.

[slimshandy69]

Yes, GGG is a top 5 p4p fighter...

[joseph5620]

Don't forget Canelo fought 40 Mcdonalds cashiers before fighting Trout and then getting a fight with Floyd and being called "The One"

Canelo is better than anybody on Golovkins resume. If you're really going to compare Golovkin's resume to Mayweather's it won't end well for Golovkin.

[The Big Dunn]

I'm a fan of GGG but the hypocrisy is ridiculous. Remember when Macklin, Barker and Murray were crap wins for Martinez over domestic level fighters.

GGG is a rising star but people need to be more realistic when discussing his resume. The skills are apparent. Eventually his resume will coincide with his talents.

Original's post was very accurate. Skills wise-GGG is one of the best fighters in the world. I'd even say he is the next level below ward, rigo and Floyd and with the right opponent could show all he has-which is a ****ing lot.

But this resume is not top 10 p4p worthy.