Resume battle: Miguel cotto or Carl Froch

[Beater_of_ass]

Cotto stays getting whooped in his major fights, froch a lot better wins and lost to ward. So it easy to call fronch better resume

Mosley and Martinez whopped Cotto? Or the Margarito rematch?

[Black Barty]

but Cotto loses are to far superior than Froch loses.
Ward and Kessler vs Pacquiao and Mayweather
Trout I thought it was just a bad night

WTeff is a "superior loss"? A loss is a loss, dude. Who has the superior WINS is what matters. I can kick get my ass kicked by Floyd and Manny, too. Is that anything to brag about?

Also, Cotto gets a pass on his worst loss because "it was just a bad night"? No bias there at all...

[jmrf4435]

Froooch by far. Here is the reason: Cotto has faced just as good comp, but loses most of his big fights. Sometimes losing them badly--froch wins them all

[Beater_of_ass]

WTeff is a "superior loss"? A loss is a loss, dude. Who has the superior WINS is what matters. I can kick get my ass kicked by Floyd and Manny, too. Is that anything to brag about?

Also, Cotto gets a pass on his worst loss because "it was just a bad night"? No bias there at all...

Manny beat Cotto down, but you are the same guy discrediting Cotto's wins against Marg and Martinez at a CW so Manny's win over Cotto should be held in the same regard. Also, Cotto did not get his ass kicked by Floyd lmao... who had the bloody nose that night? Who said it was the toughest fight of their career? It wasn't Cotto and there was only one other man in the ring fighting that night.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Which win? Martinez? Please...

Or do you mean Mosley? That's arguable.

Froch has the better resume in my opinion but the bold is NOT arguable.

[TheBoxingfan101]

Froch for me,
has never been stopped

[spytactics]

Then PWill got schooled by Quintana who Cotto smashed in 5 rounds. Pwill wasn't **** the last things I remember from his career are being put to sleep by Sergio and getting a gift decision against Lara (worse than Canelo's win somehow.) As for Martinez, who exactly avoided him? No one at 160 avoided him, he chose to call out WW's and JMW's just like Ward did, you can't duck a guy outside of your division.

Martinez went to middleweight because nobody would fight him at jmw

[Beater_of_ass]

Martinez went to middleweight because nobody would fight him at jmw

Who was at JMW when he was fighting? JMW was weaker than MW is now when Sergio was fighting there. He also moved up because Williams asked for the 157 or 158 catchweight IIRC.

[oc9979]

WTeff is a "superior loss"? A loss is a loss, dude. Who has the superior WINS is what matters. I can kick get my ass kicked by Floyd and Manny, too. Is that anything to brag about?

Also, Cotto gets a pass on his worst loss because "it was just a bad night"? No bias there at all...

He does not get a pass for having a bad night. He lost but in a rematch. I think the fight will have a different result.
So I guess you do not give credit to a fighter for facing 2 fighters that were P4P#1.

[Scipio*]

Voted for Cotto, but I'd give accomplishments for Froch.