The Official Shawn Porter-Kell Brook Master Thread

[mathed]

That is my opinion, I know many won't agree.

Body punches don't count in boxing any more or in this site.

You are very right, that is your opinion and I can't take that away from you. I just don't tend to agree but that is one of the great things about freedom of choice..I can respect every person's opinion and will try to do so in the spirit of democracy.

[ma51f]

Porter was the aggressor but didn't land.

Brook was landing the cleaner punches for most of the rounds.


Brook first says Khan needs to wait in Line & straight after next interview wants khan next. Make up your mind!

Anyway khan schools him to an easy UD

[IronDanHamza]

A draw would have been a horrible ending. No way Porter deserved to keep that belt, whether you like the way Brook fought or not, a draw would have been a robbery.

Porter didn't deserve to keep it, I agree there.

Don't really think Brook "deserved" to win it all that much either

I'm happy for Brook though.

[LacedUp]

I thought neither were in control at any point of the fight.

I had it 7-5 Brook aswell.

I can't complain with any card because the fight was that bad. Most of the rounds were hard to score.

Rhodes said the wide card was "ridiculous" I disagree.

I'm happy for Kell. I couldn't care less who won this fight I have no agenda here.

You must admit though, Kell did better than you thought he would.

Everyone who said he was going to get flattened should give him the credit he deserves.

Absolutely.

The shot he landed right before the bell in the first round drove Porter back and let him know the power was there. Kell stayed boxing and moving for the first 5 or so rounds, but when he decided it was time to meet Porter and stand firm, he took total control.

I had complete confidence that Kell would win this fight and he showed why, he is a very good fighter.

You could see Porter was extremely buzzed in the last part of the first round. His legs were shaky and his eyes dazy. Kenny Porter didn't seem to know what to do, I felt Brook could have knocked Porter out if he'd gone for it.

I was hoping that damn arrogance would come back to slap them in the face, and it did.

[LacedUp]

Porter didn't deserve to keep it, I agree there.

Don't really think Brook "deserved" to win it all that much either

I'm happy for Brook though.

I thought Porter was pretty horrible to be honest. I think he thought Kell was another Paulie Malignaggi.

[IronDanHamza]

I mean, when we talk that talk, some times people are like "This dude knows his schit"; other times people are more like: " This dude is full of schit".

We need to accept when we are on the losing side of the argument and move on.......unless there is another agenda...this is just the internet after all.

Can you guys read or no?

I-had-Brook-winning.

I'm "full of ****" because I had it close.

NSB is great.

[IronDanHamza]

I thought Porter was pretty horrible to be honest. I think he thought Kell was another Paulie Malignaggi.

There is no argument against Porter being horrible.

Wouldn't call Brook horrible but he wasn't far off.

Neither overly deserve to be Champion.

But Brook won fair and Sqaure.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Yeeeeeeeeeaahhhssssssssss!!!!!

Im going to constantly pick against my favourites from now on

[IronDanHamza]

You must admit though, Kell did better than you thought he would.

Everyone who said he was going to get flattened should give him the credit he deserves.



You could see Porter was extremely buzzed in the last part of the first round. His legs were shaky and his eyes dazy. Kenny Porter didn't seem to know what to do, I felt Brook could have knocked Porter out if he'd gone for it.

I was hoping that damn arrogance would come back to slap them in the face, and it did.

He didn't do better than I thought he would I said before the fight I won't be surprised if he wins.

His chin did better than I thought it would.

He did a lot of things worse than I thought he would.

At distance Brook was in complete control like we discussed prior to the fight. And he did enough to sc**** it (in my eyes)

[ShoulderRoll]

No those are actually true statments.

Kell said it was close, Kells trainer said there was nothing in it and Ryan Rhodes said he agreed with the draw but could have gone either way.

I had Brook edging it aswell.

Jesus me and Brooks closest people have lost their minds unlike NSB.

You're a good poster. But this fight really wasn't that close in my opinion.

What scoring criteria could possibly be used to give Porter more than 3 or 4 rounds tops? Just his hyperactive, ineffective aggression?