Greatest Junior Welters of the last 24 years

[Sugar Adam Ali]

How is Amir khan higher than Danny Garcia? Also what weight did Julio fought Sweet Pea?

julio and pernell was at welter for pernell's welter belts,, might have been at a CW like 144,145 something like that but i dont remember exactly

[Sugar Adam Ali]

ranking by who was the better fighter at 140 regardless of how long they stayed at 140

1. pernell
2. oscar
3. chavez
4. floyd
5. manny
6. tszyu
7. Hatton
8. Bradley
9. Khan
10. Zab

[Larry the boss]

wow is this a joke?

[soul_survivor]

wow is this a joke?

yeah it is, i was supposed to have floyd at no. 1, sorry.

what would your list look like nerdxxx?

ranking by who was the better fighter at 140 regardless of how long they stayed at 140

1. pernell
2. oscar
3. chavez
4. floyd
5. manny
6. tszyu
7. Hatton
8. Bradley
9. Khan
10. Zab

how does that list even work??? floyd and manny above tszyu...floyd didnt fight a single legitimate threat, how do you know how good he was at the weight?

chavez below pernell? lol wow

[Evil Abed]

It was close between those guys but Judah was so up and down but Alexander looked good except for the bradley fight. dunno what happened to him there.

Alexander looked horrible vs Kotelnik. He should have lost. He should have lost vs Matthysse.

Judah did better vs Matthysse.

Judah beat a prime Witter & Corely and Alexander beat Witter and Corely towards the end.

Judah beat Mickey Ward, Mabuza,

[Slick Veteran]

smfh @this list :*******:

Rule #1: If you're going to compile a list of great boxers - At the very least, you must be objective and unbiased.

In essence, if you harbor fanboy sentiments don't even bother, because your attempt will just end up being a public fail.

Truth

ranking by who was the better fighter at 140 regardless of how long they stayed at 140

1. pernell
2. oscar
3. chavez
4. floyd
5. manny
6. tszyu
7. Hatton
8. Bradley
9. Khan
10. Zab

Even though I disagree with some spots this is definitely a much better compiled list.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

yeah it is, i was supposed to have floyd at no. 1, sorry.

what would your list look like nerdxxx?



how does that list even work??? floyd and manny above tszyu...floyd didnt fight a single legitimate threat, how do you know how good he was at the weight?

chavez below pernell? lol wow

Read my ****ing post... Said it wasn't based on resume but who was better..

Pernell better than Chavez.. Deal with it

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

This is why I don't get into this stuff. All this crap is subjective/opinionated. Then if someone doesnt agree then they bash you.

[Cuban Linx]

I think it's a good and interesting list.

[_original_]

Don't agree with it completely but good list and you presented your case strongly, don't know why people are here complaining.