Attribute for attribute, Pacquiao is more physically gifted than Mayweather

[Evol]

JDD is back from his punishment i see?

[GOD-FR33]

Somewhat agree.

Me not accepting those losses to Bradley and Roidquez makes perfect sense. It was the same when Mosley cheated Oscar in the rematch even though Oscar still boxed his ears off. It was the same when Whitaker fought Chavez Sr.

Other than that, you had some pretty good points in your post. Hand speed is Manny all day BUT Floyd is comparable. Floyd has an edge in defense but not by much. Manny is very skilled in the way he blocks punches and his movement is better too. He is faster of hand and foot. He is stronger, despite Floyd being bigger. Manny's natural strength is a gift. His angles are something Floyd has never encountered in his career. I believe that Manny is a better boxing athelete. I don't care that Floyd is black either. I am black. Manny simply moves better in the ring. He has better legs, also. Look at the way he's built. Maidana wouldn't have been able to punish Manny like he did Floyd. Manny wouldn't be against the ropes like that. Floyd can't consistently get away from pressure fighters. This isn't anything new. I think Manny would win a decision because we all know that you cannot outwork Manny and that's why he wins.

[RichCCFC]

Yes he is.. But Floyd is the better boxer.

[-Makunouchi-]

Threads like this will always pop up, as long as floyd keeps fighting rappers in fatburger than fighting manny.

Floyd keep ducking!

[The Big Dunn]

Me not accepting those losses to Bradley and Roidquez makes perfect sense. It was the same when Mosley cheated Oscar in the rematch even though Oscar still boxed his ears off. It was the same when Whitaker fought Chavez Sr.

Other than that, you had some pretty good points in your post. Hand speed is Manny all day BUT Floyd is comparable. Floyd has an edge in defense but not by much. Manny is very skilled in the way he blocks punches and his movement is better too. He is faster of hand and foot. He is stronger, despite Floyd being bigger. Manny's natural strength is a gift. His angles are something Floyd has never encountered in his career. I believe that Manny is a better boxing athelete. I don't care that Floyd is black either. I am black. Manny simply moves better in the ring. He has better legs, also. Look at the way he's built. Maidana wouldn't have been able to punish Manny like he did Floyd. Manny wouldn't be against the ropes like that. Floyd can't consistently get away from pressure fighters. This isn't anything new. I think Manny would win a decision because we all know that you cannot outwork Manny and that's why he wins.

You said you didn't count them. That is different than not accepting them. I haven't accepted that Hagler lost to SRL, but I still count it.

You being black has no bearing on anything I posted. That you are doesn't make you unbiased.

You are entitled to your opinion. I would hope that you would also factor in Manny's problems with counterpunchers. I will remind you that floyd still wins against his "problem" opponents.

[Beercules]

JDD is back from his punishment i see?

I wonder what his other alt is

Dunn thought he was being slick

[The Big Dunn]

JDD is back from his punishment i see?

I wonder what his other alt is

Dunn thought he was being slick

What are you talking about?

[Pugilist95]

He didn't beat Juan Manuel Marquez with ease.

[Pugilist95]

Attributes, lets see:

Power: Pacquiao.

Speed: Pacquiao

Accuracy: Mayweather

Chin: Pacquiao.

Foot speed: Pacquiao

Foot movement: Mayweather (defensively), Pacquiao (Offensively)

Heart: Hard to say

IQ: Mayweather.

Head movement: Pacquiao (offensively), Mayweather (defensively)

Blocking: Mayweather.

Edit: Forgot to factor in stamina. I feel Pacquiao has the edge in that department

[Holywarrior]

Pacquiao was stopped twice with body shots. Which have nothing to do with head movement. This goes to show this dude is a boxec warrior. He sees a stoppage loss and automatically thinks from headshots.

The Torrecampo KO wasn't a bodyshot What the hell? It was an overhand left on the chin