Updated P4P List

[soul_survivor]

Let's not act like 175 is an ocean of talent. Other than Kovalev, Stevenson, and Hopkins, there aren't that many great fighters.

So? He beat the man in his division, absolutely destroyed him and beat two legit guys and avenged his only loss, all in one year. His power and skill makes him a handful for anyone p4p.

IMO any top 10 list with 4 WWs (or 4 of any one weightclass) is shit.

LOL you don't think Mayweather, Pacquiao, Bradley and JMM are amongst the very best on the planet?

get your chain smoking, skinny arse off my thread.

[Loque-san]

Decent list. But how is Canelo #11 but Lara ain't even top 25??

[Lords]

He moves Maidana up "some 10 places" because of what he did in the Floyd fight in which he LOST. That's how you know Floyd is the best, you have a whole country celebrating your performance in your defeat and you have people actually moving you up in there P4P lists

[MRCHOKEaMF]

What kinda list is that? Floyd Joy Mayweather isnt #1,#2,#3,#4, and #5 at the same time? God you must be a Pacballsniffer....god whats wrong with you haters lol.

[wiz1030]

Is Uchiyama that good? I haven't seen the guy myself

[Brandish]

1. floyd mayweather jr
2. andre ward
3. bernard hopkins
4. guillermo rigondeaux
5. adonis stevenson
6. danny garcia
7. manny pacquiao
8. wlad klit
9. sergio martinez
10. carl froch

[soul_survivor]

What kinda list is that? Floyd Joy Mayweather isnt #1,#2,#3,#4, and #5 at the same time? God you must be a Pacballsniffer....god whats wrong with you haters lol.

lol yeah I know, my bad

Is Uchiyama that good? I haven't seen the guy myself

yeah he is, watch him on youtube. terrific fighter

1. floyd mayweather jr
2. andre ward
3. bernard hopkins
4. guillermo rigondeaux
5. adonis stevenson
6. danny garcia
7. manny pacquiao
8. wlad klit
9. sergio martinez
10. carl froch

wow......garcia AND stevenson above Pacman and wlad doesnt even make the top 5? yet hopkins does......

Decent list. But how is Canelo #11 but Lara ain't even top 25??

I honestly couldn't find a place for him there, he'd make number 26. His best opponent was a slow arse ANgulo who battered and dropped him but sadly didnt have the heart to continue. the trout win was good but not great as trout has done little since beating cotto, although i still rate him.

[dan_cov]

The criteria is :

Resume
Skill, in comparison to other fighters, irregardless of weight

Golovkin 12th? The guy don't even belong on the list. There isn't a single fighter there who doesn't have a resume 5x his and as for skill, he has shown his limitations a bag of times against C level opposition a weight below.

He has done nothing. If you put the bum ass level of competition he has fought with a less skilled fighter off that list, say a Marco Huck, he'd look like the second coming of Tyson too

Its almost like having Deontay Wilder near the top 10

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Good list but i would have roman Gonzalez in the top 10..

[Scary]

1. Floyd

Rest is subjective to person writing list

You Got to have pac on your 2nd Then i agree