calzaghe > mayweather

[Showtime..]

floyd is basically the black joe calzaghe.

both fighters have never faced a legit hall of fame fighter who was in their prime.

the only reason why floyd is so much more critically acclaimed than calzaghe is the fact that he is a loud, conceited, black american whose ignorant proclamations of being so great have translated into a undeserved p4p #1 ranking.

If floyd had the same resume BUT he was a quiet japanese or swedish boxer he would have the same status as joe calzaghe.

He's only thought of so highly because he plays towards the ****** rap culture crowd.

Blind Black pride

[Box-Office]

Floyd's best wins: Corrales (unbeaten), Castillio (2nd), Zab Judah (prime), Hatton (unbeaten), Marquez, Guerrero and Miguel Cotto.

Calzaghe: Lacy (unbeaten), Kessler (unbeaten) and Hopkins.


If you take their best wins with fighters who were not over the hill then its quite clear Mayweather > Calzaghe any day. I haven't mentioned Oscar or Gatti cuz they were done and same with Eubank and Jones for Calzaghe.

[Box-Office]

what about kessler and bika?

Kessler was great, but if Bika is one of Joe's best wins then Floyd has plenty of fighters on his record who are far better than him. Giorgio Vargas is just one.

[pasawayako]

I agree. calzaghe fight the best and still undefeated while floyd duck the best to be undefeated.

[4Corners]

Floyds past prime guys like Oscar, Mosley, mayve Cotto were all still Top ranked figgters at those weight classes.

[way2strong]

someone answer this .. if the fighters fraud faced were so great were are they now?

[j.razor]

who on frauds resume can compare to beating Jones and Hopkins?

he didn't beat Hopkins and Roy was past it after he got ko'd by tarver and johnson

[rayb112]

Don't you haters think its a little funny when Floyd beats a fighter they becomes a hype job, cherry pick, weight drained, past their prime...don't you haters find it weird that Floyd has managed to payoff referees, USADA drug testers, judges and fighters to go easy on him...don't you haters think its a strange for you to make thread everyday about a person you claim to hate????

[typeone]

I think your missing the real point! Ones a boy ones a man One would fight whoever one wouldn't, One beats on women! One doesn't.. Ones a runner ones a fighter! Two totally different people.. Can't really compare to be honest

Peace

[Brandish]

I think your missing the real point! Ones a boy ones a man One would fight whoever one wouldn't, One beats on women! One doesn't.. Ones a runner ones a fighter! Two totally different people.. Can't really compare to be honest

Peace

one's a coke head the other one is not.