Has Floyd BEATEN Anybody As GOOD AS TIM BRADLEY???

[IronDanHamza]

If the question is AS GOOD as tim,, then yes, floyd has a handful of wins,, Now if your saying Better than tim, then thats really not true, floyd hasnt beaten anyone better than a prime bradley except for maybe castillo

But if your asking AS GOOD as tim, meaning equal, then i think its no doubt that floyd has

I don't think so really.

I think prime Castillo is better than Bradley, I think the version of Oscar is better than Bradley, I think prime Hatton is better than Bradley, I think Canelo could be better than Bradley (Not sure yet, time will tell), hell I think the version of Mosley is better than Bradley.

Bradley is not that good.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Also bare in mind that that is the end of 2007 when Oscar was #3.

When they fought, he was #5.

Still, he was a top fighter at 154 at the time.

that's a nice opinion you have there floyd fan.

ill stick with ring magazine's opinion.

oscar was NOT the #1 rated 154 pounder when floyd faced him.

the facts are there for those who want the truth.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Th...eweight--2000s




and im the liar now?

Title was vacant,, but if you look at the names on the list,, oscar was clearly the best,, Forrest has a case as well, but dude was so inactive, plus i thought he clearly lost to ike quartey,

regardless of the ring rankings,, i dont see a case for tim being much better than that oscar..... like i said before, its about equal

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I don't think so really.

I think prime Castillo is better than Bradley, I think the version of Oscar is better than Bradley, I think prime Hatton is better than Bradley, I think Canelo could be better than Bradley (Not sure yet, time will tell), hell I think the version of Mosley is better than Bradley.

Bradley is not that good.

I agree that castillo was better than bradley,, oscar and hatton i think are about equal to bradley.... They might be better than bradley, but not vastly better, i think they are in the same league...

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Title was vacant,, but if you look at the names on the list,, oscar was clearly the best,, Forrest has a case as well, but dude was so inactive, plus i thought he clearly lost to ike quartey,

regardless of the ring rankings,, i dont see a case for tim being much better than that oscar..... like i said before, its about equal

oscar is better than tim in the big picture resume scheme of things. I Agree, overall resume wise, oscar better than bradley.

the oscar that floyd faced IS NOT BETTER THAN THE BRADLEY THAT PACQUIAO BEAT TWICE NOW.

that is what we are talking about here.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

oscar is better than tim in the big picture resume scheme of things. I Agree, overall resume wise, oscar better than bradley.

the oscar that floyd faced IS NOT BETTER THAN THE BRADLEY THAT PACQUIAO BEAT TWICE NOW.

that is what we are talking about here.

Im not saying oscar is much better than tim,, im just stating that manny's win over tim is as good as floyd's over oscar... Not better, but equal

And the thread title is AS GOOD AS BRADLEY,, and IMO oscar win was as good as the tim win

[turkas]

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Th...eweight--2000s




and im the liar now?

Where is Winky on that list like you said? Oh yeah not in that division. Sergio? sitting at the bottom of the list. Forest? Ranked behind Oscar.

You were correct about Spinks, but a correct statement doesn't make false true.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

I don't think so really.

I think prime Castillo is better than Bradley, I think the version of Oscar is better than Bradley, I think prime Hatton is better than Bradley, I think Canelo could be better than Bradley (Not sure yet, time will tell), hell I think the version of Mosley is better than Bradley.

Bradley is not that good.

bradley was top 10 p4p, hell top 3 when pac beat him officially.

Castillo is not better than bradley come on now. castillo is your typical mexican bralwer who always gets beat by slick athletic fighters like bradley.

i know you are a hardcore floyd fan but you are one of the few good ones. Are you seriously gonna sit there and say castillo or corrales is better than bradley?

[turkas]

Dont think so. Not sure if floyd has ever beaten a top 5 p4p fighter ever in his career. he's only ever fought p4p fighters once they were clearly over the hill.


floyd's best win would probablly only qualify as manny's 3rd/4th best win.

Hatton, Marquez, Mosley, and Corrales were all ranked in the top 10 P4P when Floyd fought them. Arguably all were in the top 5 when Floyd fought them as well.

So, try again.

[IronDanHamza]

that's a nice opinion you have there floyd fan.

ill stick with ring magazine's opinion.

oscar was NOT the #1 rated 154 pounder when floyd faced him.

the facts are there for those who want the truth.

Can you read Pal?

I just clearly stated that he was ranked #5, not #1 nor #3.