Would Marquez have beaten everyone Pacquiao has beat?

[NearHypnos]

Marg at "154" for sure no.

Clottey is a bad matchup for him. JMM is a better fighter but don't like that fight for him. All things being equal he also beats Marg but Marg is a little too big for someone with JMMs style.

He beats Cotto, that version of Oscar, beats that Morales, etc etc.

Hell, I think JMM is a bad matchup for Cotto. He's a better boxer and although there's a size diff, JMM can crack and Cotto doesn't have the greatest chin on earth.. Cotto has always been hit with counters and does retreat when being hit. I could see JMM lighting him up every time he stops Cotto's charge. I only see Cotto beating JMM by stoppage...but I dont see anyone beating a younger JMM by stoppage so there's that...

Oh..and..obviously Bradley. Though if Bradley fought JMM the way he fought Pac last night...lol. Maybe things are diff.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Obviously not. Marquez is a tremendous boxer but he doesn't have the speed or athleticism to deal with much bigger guys the way Pacquaio did.

[Tay Roc]

I can't believe we never saw Marquez vs. Morales.

=(

[Chiboxing123]

Big Marquez fan but the simple answer is no

[soul_survivor]

So

MAB 2003 (Marquez beat him 2007 closely)
Morales
De La Hoya
Hatton
Cotto
Clottey
Margarito
Mosley
Bradley (Marquez lost to)


I think Marquez would have lost to Cotto, Clottey and Margarito versions Pacquiao fought.

Hell no man, he already got thoroughly outclassed by Bradley.

He barely beat the shadow of Barrera, you think he'd beat a prime Baby Faced Assassin?

Morales beats him too, Cotto at 147 beats him, Mosley might stop him, Oscar ... dont make me laugh.

he probably manages to squeeze a win over clottey.

[Fighter Pilot]

Short answer: HELL NO.

Pac's resume completely diarrheas over JMM's.

Pac would've walked through JMM's list of opponents like a hot knife through butter, but the same can't be said of JMM going through Manny's.

[bigcursedawg]

Who cares? Manny couldn't beat JMM, at 126, 130, 147, or any weight for that matter. IMO a lot of those guy are to big for Marquez and would probably beat him and just because Many was able to beat them doesn't erase the fact that JMM beat Manny clearly 3 times.

[Killer_of_Sheep]

Who cares? Manny couldn't beat JMM, at 126, 130, 147, or any weight for that matter. IMO a lot of those guy are to big for Marquez and would probably beat him and just because Many was able to beat them doesn't erase the fact that JMM beat Manny clearly 3 times.

He didn't.

[Left Hook Tua]

morales and barrera are superior to jmm

mosley, marg, clottey, cotto are all too big

hatton and rios would have roughed up jmm

kangaroo meat oscar too

hell ledwaba would probably have been a boring ass close fight with jmm

jmm is a bad matchup for pac but he is not as good as pac especially against bigger guys.

[Left Hook Tua]

I can't believe we never saw Marquez vs. Morales.

=(

jmm ducked morales after jmm ducked pac rematch

pac took the morales fight and jmm fought john