Would Marquez have beaten everyone Pacquiao has beat?

[RichCCFC]

So

MAB 2003 (Marquez beat him 2007 closely)
Morales
De La Hoya
Hatton
Cotto
Clottey
Margarito
Mosley
Bradley (Marquez lost to)


I think Marquez would have lost to Cotto, Clottey and Margarito versions Pacquiao fought.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

umm its quite obvious he cant. he lost to bradley.

[UTEP]

I think Morales would have beat him at 126 and 130.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

even old barerra dropped marquez but got no credit due to jay nady's ******ity.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

No,, jmm would lose to a prime barrera that manny fought,,

Morales would be a tough out..

JMM already lost to bradley

Cotto would crush jmm

Margs might even run over jmm....


Styles make fights, and jmm doesnt have the skillset to deal with much bigger fighters like manny has

[Dr Rumack]

I love JMM, but hell no.

[MrTambourineMan]

So

MAB 2003 (Marquez beat him 2007 closely)
Morales
De La Hoya
Hatton
Cotto
Clottey
Margarito
Mosley
Bradley (Marquez lost to)


I think Marquez would have lost to Cotto, Clottey and Margarito versions Pacquiao fought.

The bolded beat Marquez. The versions that Pacquiao faced.

[Augustane]

MAB/Morales

I wish I had an answer for these, but I think they'd go down as classics either way.

De La Hoya

De La Hoya was a skeleton, but I feel like his style would mesh up with Marquez's better that night. I favor Marquez 60-40.

Hatton

Marquez eats Hatton alive.

Cotto

Great fight. It'd be back and forth. If Marquez comes in with the power he had in JMM - Pac IV, then I think I'd favor Marquez in this match up.

Clottey

Weird fight. Clottey might be too big, but I really wonder how Marquez would fight a guy with Clottey's clam shell defense. I favor Clottey by a small margin.

Margarito

He'd be worn down and KO'd by the bigger and more relentless man. He doesn't have the movement of Pacquiao to avoid the punches over 12 rounds.

Mosley

Mosley was shot to ****. Anybody could've beat him that night.

Bradley (Marquez lost to)

We all saw what happens when Marquez has to box a boxer-mover.

[TRTboy]

No styles makes fights. Margarito, clottey, cotto IMO would have been too big for marquez because marquez does not have the footspeed or overall movement of pac to get away from those guys when he needs to. Juan Diaz and Katsidis had success against marquez. Imagine those 3. We already know he lost to Bradley.

Marquez just has the style to give pac hell. It's like he was brought to earth to do just that give pac hell in a boxing match.

[Pocket Dogs!]

Here's the thing, there's always that one opponent a boxer will always have trouble against. In Manny's case, it's Marquez.