Mayweather that beat Gatti VS Pacquaio that beat De La Hoya

[Anthony Birts]

Who wins? Why?

[clmags12]

Who wins? Why?

The Floyd that destroyed Gatti was very aggressive from the get go. While impressive the accuracy and power were always in Floyd, it was easy to put on a display against a slower face first brawler like Gatti. I enjoyed this Floyd fight.

The Manny against DLH was prime Manny. He was extremely fast and threw combos with intent. Aggressive and relentless.

If this Manny met up with any version of Floyd. Manny would have crushed him.

[Sin City]

Manny. He was more dominant.

[Jcsuper]

Manny. He was more dominant.

How can you be more dominant than Floyd vs Gatti ? Gatti didnt land one single punch of the whole fight. Also Gatti was in far more worse shape after round 6 than DLH was.

Pac fought a zombie, Floyd fought a punching bag. I don't think that these two fights should be used as an argument to explain why somebody think Floyd or Pac would win if they ever fight.

[ThePunchingBag]

Pac would land on Floyd and Pac would hurt Floyd.

Or Floyd breaks his hand early and loses a UD to the relentless onslaught of Pacquiao.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

the Floyd that fought Arturo was an aggressive version and wasn't as defensively responsible as he is now


a Floyd that is willing to come at THAT Manny and throw?


i'll take the PAC that retired DLH vs any fighter that's willing to throw with him

[Jcsuper]

the Floyd that fought Arturo was an aggressive version and wasn't as defensively responsible as he is now


a Floyd that is willing to come at THAT Manny and throw?


i'll take the PAC that retired DLH vs any fighter that's willing to throw with him

You really think Floyd would fight Pac the way he fought Gatti ? Without being more defensive ? Genius

And how can you say he wasnt defensively responsible against Gatti when Gatti didnt land a punch of the fight.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

You really think Floyd would fight Pac the way he fought Gatti ? Without being more defensive ? Genius

And how can you say he wasnt defensively responsible against Gatti when Gatti didnt land a punch of the fight.

the question was 'the floyd that fought Gatti' you ****ing ******


Gatti didn't land a punch because he was on the defensive the whole time because Floyd WAS THROWING...when you're more concerned about hitting, you're not AS defensively responsible

[DeadLikeMe]

The absolute best version of Pacquiao we have seen (aka FoTD, giantslayer, etc...) he stands like a 10% chance at Floyd...Floyd is and has always been an absolute stylistic nightmare for Pacquiao. It doesn't take anything away from Pacquiao, styles make fights is all.

[blacraven]

the Floyd that fought Arturo was an aggressive version and wasn't as defensively responsible as he is now


a Floyd that is willing to come at THAT Manny and throw?


i'll take the PAC that retired DLH vs any fighter that's willing to throw with him

This is completely false^^^^^^^^^^^^
I'm on my iPad so I cant post my videos to show you but...
If you know what your watching, Floyd showed crazy laser like accuracy and superb defence at the same time.
Times when he was popping him with like 4 left jabs with his right hand up to his ear "answering the phone" as it is called.
Blinding him with the right hand to come back with the left hook repeatedly downstairs and upstairs, then after the combo, blinding him with the left and doing it again in reverse.
Excellent footwork drills, soo much more...

Man that was a Level 144 Jedi Master Class A$$ whipping man
I really wish I could post vids and narrate.


But I always said and I stand by it...

Mayweather-Pac will basically be Mayweather-Hatton part 2.
The same exact fight with one guy extra aggresive and playing right into Floyd's hands.
He's not like other fighters, he's not going to be confused at the speed. Once he takes a few rounds to adjust to the speed and learns the timing, its a wrap from there.
All Manny ever had over Floyd was and is a punchers chance.