Your scorecards on close or controversial decisions

[Richard Wadd]

Fishnet-Quartey: Quartey 115-112
Fishnet-Tito: Fishnet 115-113
Floyd-JLC 1: 113-113
Escalera-Everett: Everett 145-140
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis 117-111
Fishnet-Nosely 2: Fishnet 115-113
SRL-Hagler: 114-114

[Daddy T]

I can't remember tbh but I believe I had hagler V Leonard, Floyd v JLC 1 and lewis v Holyfield 1 pretty similar to your scores ... though I think i gave Hagler v Leonard to leonard by a round or so and maybe JLC winning by a round or so over floyd

[IronDanHamza]

Arguello-Ramirez - Ramirez 96-94 Arguello

[bojangles1987]

Fishnet-Quartey: Quartey 115-112
Fishnet-Tito: Fishnet 115-113
Floyd-JLC 1: 113-113
Escalera-Everett: Everett 145-140
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis 117-111
Fishnet-Nosely 2: Fishnet 115-113
SRL-Hagler: 114-114

I had Quartey winning the Oscar fight 8-4 or 7-5, something like that.

I thought Oscar held on to win the Tito fight despite nearly throwing it away and beat Mosley 8-4 in the rematch.

I always have Castillo winning the first Mayweather fight 7-5.

Obviously Lewis beat Holyfield, no question whatsoever. Can't remember last time I watched it.

I will go to my grave believing Hagler beat Leonard 7-5 and got screwed.

[Jack Napier]

I had Quartey winning the Oscar fight 8-4 or 7-5, something like that.

I thought Oscar held on to win the Tito fight despite nearly throwing it away and beat Mosley 8-4 in the rematch.

I always have Castillo winning the first Mayweather fight 7-5.

Obviously Lewis beat Holyfield, no question whatsoever. Can't remember last time I watched it.

I will go to my grave believing Hagler beat Leonard 7-5 and got screwed.

all of this is spot on, especially the last line

[IMDAZED]

Fishnet-Quartey: Quartey 115-112
Fishnet-Tito: Fishnet 115-113
Floyd-JLC 1: 113-113
Escalera-Everett: Everett 145-140
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis 117-111
Fishnet-Nosely 2: Fishnet 115-113
SRL-Hagler: 114-114

We agree on everything except De La Hoya-Trinidad where I think they both deserved the loss.

[smoothsmg]

To add just two fights:

I had Cloud-Campillo a draw (Campillo lost the last two rounds on my scorecard by doing too much showboating. In the 11th, the doctor checked Cloud's cut and he took that round after that. I watched this fight four times and this was my last scorecard).

I had bradley-manny 6-5-1 for Bradley (manny took off too many large protions of rounds and Bradley was quietly landing jabs to the stomach and snuck in a few jabs to the face. pretty close ugly fight. First time i watched it, i thought Manny won the fight, but after re-watching it, I saw Bradley doing the work to win rounds while Manny was not doing the work.).

[Richard Wadd]

PEDersen-Khan: PEDerson 113-112
Fishnet-Whitaker: 113-113
Whitaker-Ramirez 1: Whitaker 116-112
Whitaker-Chavez: Whitaker 117-112
Hearns-SRL 2: Hearns 114-112
Duran-Barkley: Duran 114-113
Lewis-Mercer: 95-95
Bowe-Holy 2: 114-114
Toney-mcCallum 1: Toney 116-113
Toney-McCallum 2: McCallum 114-113
Jones-tarver 1: jones 115-113 (tarver was a whiny crybaby)
Tarver-G. Johnson 1: Tarver 115-113 (tarver had a reason to complain here)
Ward-Gatti 1: 95-95
Robinson-Gatti 1: 95-95
Freitas-Casmayor: Freitas 114-113

[bojangles1987]

Had Dirrell beating Froch 8-4. I don't care how spoilery he fought, he clearly deserved the decision in my eyes.

Had the first Kessler/Froch fight for Kessler. Not sure if it counts, but I remember a decent amount of disagreement.

[Richard Wadd]

Hopkins-taylor 1: 114-114

Hopkins-taylor 2: Hopkins 115-113

Calslappy-Hopkins: Hopkins 114-113. Although Hopkins should have had pts deducted for his acting. He blatantly headbutts calzslappy, and hits him, and then gets tapped on the groin, and acts like it was Golota-Bowe. Very beneath such a great boxer.

Mayweather-fishnet: Mayweather 116-112. Why was there any "debate" at all? People had too much to drink?

Hagler-Watts: Hagler 97-93