Your scorecards on close or controversial decisions

[Richard Wadd]

Toney-Tiberi: Tiberi 115-112
Rahman-Toney 1: 114-114
Toney-Johnson: Toney 115-112
Dawson-Johnson 1: Johnson 115-113
Spinks-Holmes 2: Holmes 144-141
Holmes-Witherspoon: Witherspoon 115-113
Hatton-Collazo: Collazo 114-113
Berto-Collazo: 114-114

[Jack Napier]

Toney-Tiberi: Tiberi 115-112
Rahman-Toney 1: 114-114
Toney-Johnson: Toney 115-112
Dawson-Johnson 1: Johnson 115-113
Spinks-Holmes 2: Holmes 144-141
Holmes-Witherspoon: Witherspoon 115-113
Hatton-Collazo: Collazo 114-113
Berto-Collazo: 114-114

Rahman beat Toney 7-5 or 8-4, Toney tired and it cost him
had Holmes beating Witherspoon 7-5
had Hatton beating Collazo by 1 point, stole it with a KD
agree with the rest
don't even remember Toney-Tiberi, need to rewatch it
Toney got a raw deal in both Griffin fights though

[Marleta]

Fishnet-Quartey: Quartey 115-112
Fishnet-Tito: Fishnet 115-113
Floyd-JLC 1: 113-113
Escalera-Everett: Everett 145-140
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis 117-111
Fishnet-Nosely 2: Fishnet 115-113
SRL-Hagler: 114-114

I do not remember all scorecards but I remember who I scored those fights for:
De la Hoya-Quartey: I had Oscar winning by 1 point.
De la Hoya vs- Trinidad: Tito won that fight. The commentary was biased and aweful.
Floyd-Castillo 1: I scored it for Castillo
Escalera-Everett: I have not seen that fight.
Lewis-Holyfield 1: I had Lewis winning by a few points.
Oscar vs Mosely 2: I think I did not score the fight, I remember it was very close.
Leonard-Hagler: Leonard won by a few points.

[Motofan]

Can't recall the scores and haven't seen some of these in a while so I'll stick to the fights Ive seen again more recently.

Oscar-Quartey: Oscar in a squeaker.
Oscar-Tito: Oscar by several rounds.
Floyd-JLC 1: Floyd in a squeaker.
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis HUGE.
SRL-Hagler: Hagler in a very close fight that could go either way.
Oscar-Mosely 2: Oscar in a close but clear win.
Pedersen-Khan: I thought it could have went either way, even with the dodgy officiating. I think I may have given it to Khan.
Whitaker-Chavez: Whitaker BIG.
Duran-Barkley: Rewatched this a month or two ago and thought it could have went either way.
Jones-tarver 1: Roy in a very close fight.
Hopkins-Taylor 1 and 2: Hopkins close in both fights.
Calzaghe- Hopkins- Zaggy by a couple rounds.
Hatton-Collazo: I gave it to Ricky CLOSE, but could have been bias on my part. Id have to see it again.

[Richard Wadd]

Hagler-Antufermo 1: Hagler 144-141

[DreamMerchant12]

Only ones I remember were Andre Dirrell 8-4 against Froch, 115-111 Floyd over JLC, and Pacquiao 115-113 over Bradley in their first fight.

[Holywarrior]

Fishnet-Quartey: Fishnet 114-112 iirc
Fishnet-Tito: Fishnet 115-113
Floyd-JLC 1: 114-112
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis 117-111
Fishnet-Nosely 1/2: Mosley 116-112/ 2: Fishnet 116-112
SRL-Hagler: 115-113
Fishnets - Sturm - Sturm 115-113
Whitaker-Chavez: Whitaker 117-111

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Fishnet-Quartey: Quartey 115-112
Fishnet-Tito: Fishnet 115-113
Floyd-JLC 1: 113-113
Escalera-Everett: Everett 145-140
Lewis-Holy 1: Lewis 117-111
Fishnet-Nosely 2: Fishnet 115-113
SRL-Hagler: 114-114

oscar 113-112 over quartey

floyd 114-112 over JLC (castillo gave away too many early rounds)

lewis 117-111 over holyfield

Oscar 115-113 over mosely 2

SRL 115-113 over hagler,, (Hagler gave away too many early rounds)

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Toney-Tiberi: Tiberi 115-112
Rahman-Toney 1: 114-114
Toney-Johnson: Toney 115-112
Dawson-Johnson 1: Johnson 115-113
Spinks-Holmes 2: Holmes 144-141
Holmes-Witherspoon: Witherspoon 115-113
Hatton-Collazo: Collazo 114-113
Berto-Collazo: 114-114

Tiberi 115-113 over toney

Johnson 115-113 over dawson

Collazo 114-113 over hatton

Collazo 115-113 over Berto

Holmes over spinks 2 143-142

Holmes over Witherspoon 143-142

[mrlopez]

I will go to my grave believing Hagler beat Leonard 7-5 and got screwed.

same here! still pisses me off when i see a replay or a show talking about it!