Who's better: Roy Jones or Pernell Whitaker?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

roy jones jr ... who the *** did whitaker beat ? he's a HOF at most not a ATG



edit: make up a number for the guy then make sure to throw de la hoya 15-25 numbers ahead of him

this is so full of fail, it made me leave the thread

[IronDanHamza]

and got knocked out by a journey man mexican cab driver years before when chavez sr was in his prime and whitaker wanted nothing to do with him

Who did???

[Ham Porter]

All Pernell Whitaker needed was a challenge, which is why he moved up to 154.


The fact that this move up in weight coincided with Terry Norris losing his belt is purely coincidental.

[way2strong]

this is so full of fail, it made me leave the thread

why is that man did i lie or something? what makes him a ATG over someone like oscar de la hoya who everyone discredits around here

[way2strong]

Who did???

cuhz got slept nah he didn't get slept but he did get his ass handed to him and handed his first lost by a journeyman when he could have stepped up to the plate he fought chavez when he was leaving his prime moving up into a new weight division

[Richard Wadd]

ramirez was a good fighter, but got a gift against whitaker.

whitaker-chavez would indeed have been better in the late 80s at 135, although whitaker still wins (unless the judges are drunk and rob him again)

[IronDanHamza]

cuhz got slept nah he didn't get slept but he did get his ass handed to him and handed his first lost by a journeyman when he could have stepped up to the plate he fought chavez when he was leaving his prime moving up into a new weight division

Who did? Whitaker?

Are you talking about the Ramirez robbery?

Are you calling Ramirez a journeyman?

You're an idiot

"Knocked out by a journeyman"

[Emon723]

I remember when they were seriously considering a fight.

Sweet Pea wants Roy at 157 after he beat Vasquez for a fourth world title.

[bose]

whitiker is from differnt era where fighters fought the best, challenged themselfs. roy great fighter and should have done more.

Whitiker stands ahead of Roy.

[Leonard Eller B]

Who did? Whitaker?

Are you talking about the Ramirez robbery?

Are you calling Ramirez a journeyman?

You're an idiot

"Knocked out by a journeyman"

I just opted to not even respond to the guy. Let the idiots hang themselves.