Who's better: Roy Jones or Pernell Whitaker?

[VG_Addict]

This isn't about who would win in a fight between them, this is about who's ranked higher P4P. They were both ranked at the top of the P4P list in the 90s, but who ranks higher P4P all time?

[way2strong]

roy jones jr ... who the *** did whitaker beat ? he's a HOF at most not a ATG



edit: make up a number for the guy then make sure to throw de la hoya 15-25 numbers ahead of him

[7_rocket]

Is this even a serious thread?

[Leonard Eller B]

I remember when they were seriously considering a fight.

[SweetPbfAli]

roy jones jr ... who the *** did whitaker beat ? he's a HOF at most not a ATG



edit: make up a number for the guy then make sure to throw de la hoya 15-25 numbers ahead of him

Couldn't figure out your position until i looked at your Avatar.

[Leonard Eller B]

roy jones jr ... who the *** did whitaker beat ? he's a HOF at most not a ATG



edit: make up a number for the guy then make sure to throw de la hoya 15-25 numbers ahead of him

He beat the hell out of Chavez Sr.

[SweetPbfAli]

I remember when they were seriously considering a fight.

Yep. Sweet Pea is my favorite fighter but that would have been suicidal. Ring had a cover dedicated to that when they were p4p 1 and 2.

[Richard Wadd]

whitaker ranks higher

[_original_]

Sweet Pea for sure.

[way2strong]

He beat the hell out of Chavez Sr.

and got knocked out by a journey man mexican cab driver years before when chavez sr was in his prime and whitaker wanted nothing to do with him