Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Latest Pound-for-Pound Update

[MarkPosadas26]

BS list. why does Rigondeaux on No. 3 spot? what does he do? Klitschko at No. 2? WTF? and Tim Bradley who has two (2) controversial wins against Manny and Provo? and Gayweather who has 45-0 with no legit opponents and now rumored fighting A mere Con? Why America? why? lol!

[royjonesjrKTFO]

Mickey's resume I think is better than Rigo.

P4P isn't about who has the better resume.

It's about abilities / talent / skills, etc.

[royjonesjrKTFO]

This is a great list I've seen in awhile except Froch is NOT P4P caliber. All he is is just a tough guy w/ average skills, and a good chin. We talking Pound-4-Pound BEST here. Replace him with Gennady Golovkin. Wlad Klitschko is a heavyweight, which the P4P lists isn't meant for. He's a Super huge guy fighting in the weakest division in all of boxing playing keep away using his height and jab. Imagine him without those advantages. I think he'd have a bunch of KO losses on his record.

[Martinplateado]

Roman Gonzalez & Danny Garcia above Sergio Martinez?, wth

[Garrett3]

BS list. why does Rigondeaux on No. 3 spot? what does he do? Klitschko at No. 2? WTF? and Tim Bradley who has two (2) controversial wins against Manny and Provo? and Gayweather who has 45-0 with no legit opponents and now rumored fighting A mere Con? Why America? why? lol!

You could nitpick anyone's resume... Just like I can say PAC is coming off one of the worse knock outs in history... Why does he deserve a top spot from beating a 23rd ranked WW?