Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Latest Pound-for-Pound Update

[bojangles1987]

I dont get how you can possibly leave Wlad off the top 10. He's my #4

Because there's an obvious way you can look at Wladimir Klitschko skills, see his crap opposition, and realize he isn't one of the 10 best fighters in the world.

I love the list. I pretty much fully agree with the whole thing.

[Weltschmerz]

Because there's an obvious way you can look at Wladimir Klitschko skills, see his crap opposition, and realize he isn't one of the 10 best fighters in the world.

I love the list. I pretty much fully agree with the whole thing.

This is complete rubbish. Wlad isn't lacking any skill in any department. Also, Cliff Rold said Wlad could easily be on the list. It comes down to matter of personal taste, in the end. But claiming Wlad not to be a top fighter is frivolous. You might not like his style; doesn't take away that he's a quality fighter.

[bojangles1987]

This is complete rubbish. Wlad isn't lacking any skill in any department. Also, Cliff Rold said Wlad could easily be on the list. It comes down to matter of personal taste, in the end. But claiming Wlad not to be a top fighter is frivolous. You might not like his style; doesn't take away that he's a quality fighter.

Wlad has no ability to fight inside whatsoever, and the idea of doing so clearly scares him. As evident by his need to grab hold of his opponent the moment they are within reach. He shouldn't even be allowed to fight the way he has too many times.

Jab, clinch. Jab, clinch. Jab, right, clinch. Clinch. Clinch. Jab, clinch. Real skillful.

[DARKSEID]

Garcia over Martinez?

That's a joke.

Also you admitted Marquez was limited and was lacking in creating his own offense yet you put him as the number 5 pound for pound fighter in the world.

B-Scene is as good at making lists as they are at making predictions.

[Grimgash]

Wlad lost a ton of fans recently and his skill set looks weak compared to p4p lists. He did a lot of holding clinching and using his weight last fight....p4p that won't fly when you're not a vastly bigger man. I agree with the list to be honest, i can make changes but nothing drastic and it's not bad. Also Manny lost to two guys ranked p4p higher than him....he didn't lose to an unranked nobody. Though JMM I feel shouldn't be that high on the list tbh....wish he'd fight prov or porter and get scratched off....but for now you can't.

[Grimgash]

Garcia over Martinez?

That's a joke.

B-Scene is as good at making lists as they are at making predictions.

Dannys fought top notch guys and wins as an underdog. Sergio looked like crap against Murray. He beat on Chavez but took a beating in the 12th...and Chavez can barely make 168 let alone 160. Sergios stock has plummeted and it's time to accept that. Even if he beats Cotto it won't say much about it.

[DARKSEID]

Dannys fought top notch guys and wins as an underdog. Sergio looked like crap against Murray. He beat on Chavez but took a beating in the 12th...and Chavez can barely make 168 let alone 160. Sergios stock has plummeted and it's time to accept that. Even if he beats Cotto it won't say much about it.

Well this is a pound for pound list.

Pound for pound, who has more power? Martinez
Who has more speed? Martinez
Who has a better jab? Martinez
Who has more angles? Martinez
Who has better footwork? Martinez
Who has a better defense? Martinez

How is Garcia a better fighter than Martinez? Sergio is in my Top 3 PFP. Nobody beats him in or around his weight class.

[zuz]

Hmmm.. Wlad really got spanked for the Povetkin fight, huh?

Povetkin is a bum who's lost to cruiserweight Huck.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

What do Wlad's right hand and Haley's comet have in common?




They both show up every 75 years.

[H.B.Viper]

OK then getting KTFO

if you want a p4p based on WIN RECORDs without considering other factors, you came at the wrong place. P4P are based on lots of factors, not only by WIN Records, its based on how they perform on their fights, quality of opponents etc.

Constitutes for a higher p4p ranking over pure dominance, ring savvy, and true respect by the fighters in your division?
Ask all the middleweights, even GGG knows Martinez is still king.
As well as of the heavyweights, they know the king of the mt.are still the Bros.
One was kayo'd, the other clearly outclassed. What does that say about those rankings & who runs them?
I'm done. I'm lost for words.....