My personalized pound for pound list

[kurt0411]

JMM for a start. He's simply not the fighter he was 5 years ago. I would also remove Martinez from the list completely if it's based off recent form.

You really think Jmm will beat pac again? Come on dude, yes he's got his number but there's no chance in hell he can beat manny again, manny will be way too motivated for that match up

[MBE]

You really think Jmm will beat pac again? Come on dude, yes he's got his number but there's no chance in hell he can beat manny again, manny will be way too motivated for that match up

The bold part says it all.

When Pacquiao tried to box, he got beat although unofficially in their third fight. When he decided to go balls out he got stretched.

You can't say he wasn't motivated, this isn't Chavez jr. we're talking about here. He was highly motivated in all their fights because of the controversy.

And what's happened since? Going 12 rounds with a journeyman doesn't make you the second best in the world.

[Xi_]

That's why I'm excluding their resumes completely, I'm saying as in if they fought right now, who would win?

then how is ggg over rigo.......rigo would beat ggg like he stole something if they were the same size.

[soul_survivor]

So you think bradley will beat pac?

I actually don't but until Pac gets that win, I can't rank Pac higher.

[kurt0411]

I actually don't but until Pac gets that win, I can't rank Pac higher.

But that's the point of my pound for pound list, it depends on right now. Right now pac would beat everyone except floyd period.

[DeadLikeMe]

The bold part says it all.

When Pacquiao tried to box, he got beat although unofficially in their third fight. When he decided to go balls out he got stretched.

You can't say he wasn't motivated, this isn't Chavez jr. we're talking about here. He was highly motivated in all their fights because of the controversy.

And what's happened since? Going 12 rounds with a journeyman doesn't make you the second best in the world.

Journeyman implies you actually were someone at some point. People were calling him Bum Bum Rios years before he lost his way into a Pac fight. Rios isn't a journeyman, a has been, or a gatekeeper...he is a never was.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Floyd
Ward
Rigo
Bradley
Jmm
Manny
Wlad
Danny
Mickey
Roman gonzales

[kurt0411]

Floyd
Ward
Rigo
Bradley
Jmm
Manny
Wlad
Danny
Mickey
Roman gonzales

Again if that's meant to be a "regular" pound for pound list, then you missed the point of this thread.

[Kuyukut]

FIRST THIS IS NOT A REGULAR POUND FOR POUND LIST.

This pound for pound list determines which fighters are the best right now, excluding any of their previous encounters ( I don't know if I explained it properely)

1) mayweather
2) pacquiao
3) ward
4) golovkin
5) rigo
6) klitschko
7) bradley
8) martinez
9) marquez
10) kovalev

Anyone I missed? What do you guys think?

Also if anyone understood my point and can explain it better, please do

the only problem i have with your list is, why in the world a scared coward is #1?

[The Problem Child]

I like that list!! Except for Ward... he does not belong in the top P4P IMHO. At best, he should be 9-10. Martinez is debatable as well... he got slapped around by weeded up version of Chavez Jr and beat a drunken fighter in Pavlik. P Will as dangerous as he was, was a very vulnerable fighter. Martinez got beat by Margarito as well. IMO he is not P4P material either.