Duran lost biggest fights yet PFP great.

[MrTambourineMan]

I have him at 60-80 depending on if you can make a case for him being higher then 60. I can't so I have him around 72 last time I checked.

PAC is two years younger then Floyd yet only has 6 title defenses Floyd has 15 defenses it's not really comparable when you measure Floyd vs PAC.

Floyd is #1 ATG at 130
Top ten @135
Top ten @140
Top ten @ 147
Top ten @ 154


Can't say the same for PAC in any weight class

You vile little Troglodyte.

[Brandish]

You vile little Troglodyte.

Another f.u.c.k.i.n.g ******"peeleft:

[Brandish]

Floyd top ten at 140???

Are you serious? Haha. how the hell did you reach that conclusion?

There cannot be a serious case made for him being top 10 of many of these weightclasses in my opinion.

Same can be said of Duran at 147, 154, 160, **** Duran didn't defend not one of his titles outside if 135. Glorified belt picker.

[IronDanHamza]

I have him at 60-80 depending on if you can make a case for him being higher then 60. I can't so I have him around 72 last time I checked.

PAC is two years younger then Floyd yet only has 6 title defenses Floyd has 15 defenses it's not really comparable when you measure Floyd vs PAC.

Floyd is #1 ATG at 130
Top ten @135
Top ten @140
Top ten @ 147
Top ten @ 154

Can't say the same for PAC in any weight class

Floyd's obviously not Top 10 at 135 and 147, but let's forget those for a second.

How on Earth is Floyd top 10 at 140 and 154??? He has three fights at 140 and three at 154.

How can Mayweather be Top 10 at 140 when all he's done at 140 is beat a passed prime Gatti and Demarcus Corley?

[bojangles1987]

Brandish suckered a lot of people. I have to respect that. Too bad he didn't go all the way with his criteria and put Calzaghe in the top 10.

[Daddy T]

Brandish suckered a lot of people. I have to respect that. Too bad he didn't go all the way with his criteria and put Calzaghe in the top 10.

joe is the wrong color doe

[bojangles1987]

joe is the wrong color doe

Yeah, true.

[LacedUp]

Same can be said of Duran at 147, 154, 160, **** Duran didn't defend not one of his titles outside if 135. Glorified belt picker.

I never claimed Duran was the greatest at any of those weightclasses. But he's without question one of, if not the best LW there ever was.

But come on, answer the question. How did you reach the conclusion that Floyd is a top 10 140 of all times?

[StarshipTrooper]

Don't make excuses the criteria for ATG is how many title defense did said ATG have Buchanan 3 title defenses dejesus 1 those are not ATG

Run that criteria for ATG past any legit boxing historian and watch you get laughed out of the building.

[Dean_Razorback]

so, floyd fighting 3 times at 154 against a past prime de la hoya, a beaten cotto and canelo at a catch weight makes him a top ten in the division?