Who has the greatest resume, Tyson Or Holyfield?

[IronDanHamza]

Definitely Holyfield but I'll take a prime Tyson over a prime Holyfield. Then again Holy did beat up a horse.

The Horse beat him up!

Holyfield said he hurt his hand on the Horse's jaw.

True story, that's what he said.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Holyfield's HW resume is much better than Tyson's let alone his overall resume.

Ironically i think mike had a better title reign,, whereas holyfield had big wins but his actual reign was very shallow

mike beat berbick
smith
pink
tucker
biggs
holmes
tubbs
spinks
bruno
williams
then lost to buster
cameback and beat bruno
defended and unified vs seldon

holy beat buster
foreman
cooper
holmes
lost to bowe
then regained from bowe but lost it to moorer
then regained from tyson and defended it vs
tyson
moorer
bean
lewis (draw)

then beat ruiz, but then lost to ruiz

Tyson's first title reign was much better than holyfields title reign IMO but obviously holyfield had much bigger wins throughout his career, plus all the cruiser accolades

[MGMGRAND]

Good answers so far, I would have thought that most would choose Tyson, since they always include him in fantasy fights, such as Tyson Vs Ali or Tyson Vs Foreman.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Definitely Holyfield but I'll take a prime Tyson over a prime Holyfield. Then again Holy did beat up a horse.

Tyson prime or not, would never beat holyfield,,, He just has his number

much like MAB will never beat manny,,,or mosely vs forrest

[bojangles1987]

The Real Deal by far.

[killerbunny88]

My vote goes to Tyson...

[MGMGRAND]

Tyson prime or not, would never beat holyfield,,, He just has his number

much like MAB will never beat manny,,,or mosely vs forrest

Do you think that Lewis would have always beaten Tyson as well?

[hugh grant]

Real deal has better resume than LL as well.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Do you think that Lewis would have always beaten Tyson as well?

Not sure about that as i am with holyfield,,,

Lewis was great, but a prime tyson would have tagged him alot early and often..
I cant really give you a pick on that one,, its 50/50 IMO. Tyson would start fast and lewis would come on late..

If i had to make a choice i would say lewis probably takes him due to his size, jab, and skills,

[IronDanHamza]

Tyson prime or not, would never beat holyfield,,, He just has his number

much like MAB will never beat manny,,,or mosely vs forrest

I'm not sure, I think 1990 would have been a great fight, great great fight and I'm not sure who I'd pick to win.

Holyfield was well well passed it in 96 but I think 96 Holyfield was much better than 96 Tyson (Although it didn't seem that way at the time)