Roy Jones Jr Vs Floyd Mayweather Jr, who has the better resume?

[ironmt]

fraud has no wins on his resume even close to Toney and Hopkins and thats a fact jack.

This says all that needs to be said.

[BUNGALOWS]

unbiasedly speaking, jones gutted out a win on a peaking antonio tarver, a fighter most claimed he was ducking...floyd, well you know the rest...lol

Good point. Floyd's a ***** ass hoe.

[BattlingNelson]

Good question. I wonder who fought the most top 3 competition.

[Jam Jars]

Who did Jones beat that were in the P4P top 10 when he beat them. Toney and?..............

[Gods We Faked]

Who did Jones beat that were in the P4P top 10 when he beat them. Toney and?..............

Which of Floyds wins is even that good though?

[IronDanHamza]

Good question. I wonder who fought the most top 3 competition.

Mayweather.

Mayweather's fought some of the most Top 3-5 ranked fighers in the history of the sport and certainly in modern history.

Roy Jones resume is still better though.

[BattlingNelson]

Mayweather.

Mayweather's fought some of the most Top 3-5 ranked fighers in the history of the sport and certainly in modern history.

Roy Jones resume is still better though.

I was thinking in the respective weightdivision in which they fought. I dont have the answer straight of the bat, but I'd think that Jones would have the edge.

[IronDanHamza]

I was thinking in the respective weightdivision in which they fought. I dont have the answer straight of the bat, but I'd think that Jones would have the edge.

I'm talking about in the respective weight division they fought.

And, it's Mayweather.

Mayweather has beaten more fighters in the Top 5 (Of the respective divison being fought) than many in history and certainly more than most in modern history.

[IronDanHamza]

Here's the list;

Floyd Mayweather;

130
Gernaro Hernandez - #1
Angel Manfredy- #2
Diego Corrales - #1
Jesus Chavez - #3

135
Jose Luis Castillo - #1
Jose Luis Castillo - #1

140
Arturo Gatti - #1

147
Zab Judah - #3
Carlos Baldomir - #1
Shane Mosley - #1
Victor Ortiz - #2
Robert Guerrero - #2

154
Oscar De La Hoya - #3
Miguel Cotto - #1
Canelo Alvarez- #1


Roy Jones;

168
James Toney - #1
Vinny Pazienza - #5

175
Montel Griffin- #4
Vigil Hill - #1
Reggie Johnson - #4
Eric Harding-#3
Antonio Tarver - #1

Heavyweight
John Ruiz - #5

Mayweather - 15

Jones - 8

[FeFist]

It's a bit of a weird situation in the sense that if Floyd had 2 A plus names on his resume, it would be superior to Roy Jones Jr by far in my honest opinion. However that isn't the case, he has a bunch of good wins but none of them are great so RJJ edges him in my books.