ESPN's Latest Top Ten P4P

[HanzGruber]

Rigo in the top 10... WTF? I'm sorry he did beat Donaire but with only 12 fights that should not count in my book. Cotto makes more sense due to who he has fought and how long as a professional. Danny should also be top 10 I couldn't agree more, the guy OWNS the 140 pound division.

coming off 2 losses and beating a journey man means p4p lol k

[DannYankee]

Donaire over Danny Garcia

I'd swap Donaire with Mikey Garcia.

Just my thoughts both of them Donaire doesn't deserve to be p4p his spot was taken why does he get back in there before those 2 guys because he beat geriatric Vic?

[-PBP-]

Dan Rafael is a known Donaire fanboy. It doesn't surprise me that he's on there.

[Lords]

LOL@ Andrea at number 2.

ALSO, until Martinez stops hiding... that spot belongs to Triple G.

Justify GGG being in the top 10, he has fought absolutely nobody. Beating Stevens doesn't put you their. He shouldn't even be an honorable mention.

[CubanGuyNYC]

Rigo in the top 10... WTF? I'm sorry he did beat Donaire but with only 12 fights that should not count in my book. Cotto makes more sense due to who he has fought and how long as a professional. Danny should also be top 10 I couldn't agree more, the guy OWNS the 140 pound division.

At the time Rigo beat Donaire, Nonito was widely considered number four P4P. Beyond that, many people, including myself, felt that Guille's abilities were P4P. Donaire seemed to confirm that. However, I agree that Garcia should've earned a spot on the list after beating Matthysse.

[CubanGuyNYC]

Dan Rafael is a known Donaire fanboy. It doesn't surprise me that he's on there.

From the looks of it, there were ten "experts" on the panel.

[-PBP-]

From the looks of it, there were ten "experts" on the panel.

Yeah but look how they rated. Somebody rated him 3rd which gives him 8 points. That's where most of his points come from. If he wasn't rated 3rd by one of the "experts" he wouldn't even be on the list.

[CubanGuyNYC]

Yeah but look how they rated. Somebody rated him 3rd which gives him 8 points. That's where most of his points come from. If he wasn't rated 3rd by one of the "experts" he wouldn't even be on the list.

Good point. That third place vote (and I agree it may very well have been Dan's) got Donaire on the list. Then again, if Nonito hadn't gained either of those two seventh place votes, he wouldn't have made the cut either. There were two other voters, besides Rafael, that still think highly of Donaire.

[Access_Denied]

Absolutely dreadful list. I've seen much better lists from posters on here.

[mathed]

Martinez gets so much disrespect, it's sickening.