If anyone has Broner top 10 pfp, shouldn't they have Mikey higher??

[_original_]

Neitherr should be P4p so if anyone has them there, they aren't very smart anyways.

Garcia deserves to be in the top 10 IMO.

[RlCKY]

Not much to say about this.

Broner has a good win over Demarco

Garcia has Salido, the ghost of Juanma, and now Martinez.

3 to 1, Garcia!, Jim!

[Kagami Taiga]

Garcia deserves to be in the top 10 IMO.

No he really doesn't unless u mean danny Garcia who actually has a better resume than mikey

[Black Barty]

Their resumes are pretty similar imo. Both have only two wins of real substance.

Demarco = Salido: top 3 guy in a weak, wide open division, would be a fringe contender in a stronger class.

Malignaggi = Martinez: paper titlist and top 10 guy in the division, but clearly below the elite.

So I would say they are equals in terms of P4P standing, and neither is in my top 10.

[Kagami Taiga]

As far as resumes go I give the edge to mikey. But that can easily change next month with a Broner win over Maidana.

[MRCHOKEaMF]

Not much to say about this.

Broner has a good win over Demarco

Garcia has Salido, the ghost of Juanma, and now Martinez.

3 to 1, Garcia!, Jim!

Really...nah really, Juanma? That counts as a good win you must mean another Juanma....lol. Really? I know alot of you hate him because of his high KO rate and that he always comes forward for a KO, that he had to beat 3 champions to get those belts, that he called out Maidana and that he said he would fight whoever the fans voted for, which he is doing. I know you guys hate him for what he does in the ring being 24 and a 3 division champion, i guess he's hated for just playing defense and boxing, as opposed to trying to be exciting and get the KO. Yeah I can see why. But damn...you put Juanma in as a good win? you must really hate him. lol

[_original_]

No he really doesn't unless u mean danny Garcia who actually has a better resume than mikey

Both Garcias lol

Look, after the top 5, a P4P list today becomes very subjective and it's not insane to suggest that Garcia is top 9-10.

[Kagami Taiga]

Both Garcias lol

Look, after the top 5, a P4P list today becomes very subjective and it's not insane to suggest that Garcia is top 9-10.

Danny doesn't belong there. He just doesn't. His resume is decent but outside of salido and Martinez, it's pretty crap.

EDIT: I meant mikey doesn't belong here.

[Weebler I]

Hmmm Broner is a 3 DIVISION Champion, Garcia just made his first defense of his first title. Troll thread, troll hates Broner, and wanted to downplay the guys accomplishments. The hate is strong in this one.

It's a good question, is beating fighters in multiple divisions more impressive?

[Kagami Taiga]

It's a good question, is beating fighters in multiple divisions more impressive?

Hard to say yes in Broner's case. He never beat any special fighters at 130. The up two wins at 135 and 147 are quality tho. And a win over Maidana would be big too.