Danny Garcia not being in the p4p list is a travesty

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Spray_resistant
    Vacant interim regular(C)
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Feb 2009
    • 29503
    • 2,907
    • 1,531
    • 53,384

    #11
    Originally posted by True Alpha Male
    I rate Danny higher than Bradley....Bradley got a gift against Pac and beat and old man in Marquez.

    Danny beats the guy who many claimed would destroy him in 3 rounds, they gave him no chance....Danny shut the haters up and knocked Matthysse down and beat him convincingly.

    It seems like there is nothing Garcia can do to earn people's respect.
    He could be on there but plenty of good fighters you could rate over him, honestly he really only has three notable wins.

    Comment

    • hectari
      Power to the People
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Jan 2005
      • 22896
      • 1,430
      • 768
      • 131,802

      #12
      Originally posted by Hurtin-Bombs
      this place has the worst p4p list by far imo
      Danny Garcia is at least number 10 on Boxingscene p4p list.

      But seriously if any other fighter say Pacquiao fought those guys Garcia fought you would criticize him.

      If Pac beat Khan, Judah, and Mattysse would you praise those wins too?

      I think Danny is good but you have to hold him up to the same standard and criticize him and nitpick his wins hard. If Morales was shot when Pac fought him, what does that mean about Garcia? and in the first fight Erik gave Garcia trouble a bloated sluggish walking corpse.

      Danny is on the right path after the Lucas fight though, he should be getting some big name guys soon. If I were him I would stay away from Floyd, Danny is basically the Puerto Rican version of Canelo same style plodding but with good boxing. Floyd would tag him and get out all night.

      Comment

      • Frank Ducketts
        Floyd's jizz
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • May 2010
        • 10021
        • 291
        • 67
        • 16,378

        #13
        Danny belongs on everyones pfp list.

        Comment

        • hectari
          Power to the People
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Jan 2005
          • 22896
          • 1,430
          • 768
          • 131,802

          #14
          Originally posted by Spray_resistant
          He could be on there but plenty of good fighters you could rate over him, honestly he really only has three notable wins.
          yeah I can't believe the op actually said he rates Danny over Bradley?

          lol

          Bradley has fought everyone, he was the man at 140 too he basically cleaned out the division and he never ducked Khan, Khan was with goldenboy and Bradley went for a better opponent in Pacman and got the nod.

          Garcia's resume doesn't even hold a candle to Bradley's. Weak Chin khan, bloated super washed up Morales and past prime judah? If we are going to criticize other fighters we must criticize him he doesn;t get a pass.

          Comment

          • bojangles1987
            bo jungle
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Jul 2009
            • 41118
            • 1,326
            • 357
            • 63,028

            #15
            Timothy Bradley has earned his p4p spot over years of hard work, not just by beating Marquez. Which, by itself, was a greater accomplishment than Garcia beating Matthysse.

            Danny should be on there, but not over Tim.

            Comment

            • Hurtin-Bombs
              Banned
              • Oct 2013
              • 167
              • 6
              • 0
              • 214

              #16
              Originally posted by hectari
              Danny Garcia is at least number 10 on Boxingscene p4p list.

              But seriously if any other fighter say Pacquiao fought those guys Garcia fought you would criticize him.

              If Pac beat Khan, Judah, and Mattysse would you praise those wins too?

              I think Danny is good but you have to hold him up to the same standard and criticize him and nitpick his wins hard. If Morales was shot when Pac fought him, what does that mean about Garcia? and in the first fight Erik gave Garcia trouble a bloated sluggish walking corpse.

              Danny is on the right path after the Lucas fight though, he should be getting some big name guys soon. If I were him I would stay away from Floyd, Danny is basically the Puerto Rican version of Canelo same style plodding but with good boxing. Floyd would tag him and get out all night.
              What does Manny have to do with this? He's 1-2 in his last 3 against guys he was supposed to beat easily.

              Garcia is the clear #1 guy in what was the deepest division in boxing until he cleared the smoke. He deserves to be there.

              How is Pacquiao above him? Sorry but beating Matthysse and Judah is better than getting outboxed and then KTFO like Pacquiao did.

              and the fact that Wlad isn't even there is hilarious.

              Comment

              • True Alpha Male
                Banned
                Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                • Oct 2013
                • 456
                • 23
                • 6
                • 567

                #17
                Originally posted by hectari
                yeah I can't believe the op actually said he rates Danny over Bradley?

                lol

                Bradley has fought everyone, he was the man at 140 too he basically cleaned out the division and he never ducked Khan, Khan was with goldenboy and Bradley went for a better opponent in Pacman and got the nod.

                Garcia's resume doesn't even hold a candle to Bradley's. Weak Chin khan, bloated super washed up Morales and past prime judah? If we are going to criticize other fighters we must criticize him he doesn;t get a pass.
                Bradley is overrated, a robbery against Pac and beating an old man doesn't cut it.

                Danny is better than Bradley, has a better resume too.

                Comment

                • Rudiamonds
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Aug 2012
                  • 2172
                  • 76
                  • 1
                  • 8,938

                  #18
                  The fact that they got broner on the list and not Garcia is a disgrace

                  Comment

                  • Spray_resistant
                    Vacant interim regular(C)
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 29503
                    • 2,907
                    • 1,531
                    • 53,384

                    #19
                    Originally posted by hectari
                    yeah I can't believe the op actually said he rates Danny over Bradley?

                    lol

                    Bradley has fought everyone, he was the man at 140 too he basically cleaned out the division and he never ducked Khan, Khan was with goldenboy and Bradley went for a better opponent in Pacman and got the nod.

                    Garcia's resume doesn't even hold a candle to Bradley's. Weak Chin khan, bloated super washed up Morales and past prime judah? If we are going to criticize other fighters we must criticize him he doesn;t get a pass.
                    Even without the Pac win which I don't give credit to Timmy for he should certainly be more highly rated than Danny who is getting better always it seems but needs to show he can hang on top for sometime against solid opponents.

                    Comment

                    • hectari
                      Power to the People
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Jan 2005
                      • 22896
                      • 1,430
                      • 768
                      • 131,802

                      #20
                      Originally posted by Hurtin-Bombs
                      What does Manny have to do with this? He's 1-2 in his last 3 against guys he was supposed to beat easily.

                      Garcia is the clear #1 guy in what was the deepest division in boxing until he cleared the smoke. He deserves to be there.

                      How is Pacquiao above him? Sorry but beating Matthysse and Judah is better than getting outboxed and then KTFO like Pacquiao did.

                      and the fact that Wlad isn't even there is hilarious.
                      It has to do with alot, I see you put down Pacman, but you don't nitpick Garcia's wins. You also were probably one of the guys when pacman was reigning hating on his wins.

                      If you are going to hold Pac to some high standard you must do the same for Garcia.

                      This has nothing to do with the past prime version of Pacman.

                      so tell me if Pac beat Zab, Khan, and Lucas would you give him the same praise or would you just say Zab was old, Khan had a weak chin, and Lucas was unproven tailormade for Pac?

                      Stop bein biased I love calling you guys out its fun. If you pick on one guy you must put every fight tot he same standard.

                      To me right now Tim Bradley is the best in the world, he is better than Garcia too.

                      Danny Garcia is good but he is a plodder, like Canelo.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP