Pound 4 Pound #1

[moy22487]

Has to be Pacman.

Destroyed 3 Mexican legends.

Thoughts

PBF is #2 arguably but who has he beaten? Gatti? Chico?

Thoughts?

gatti chico castillo twice cahvez corely agustus and hernandeez thats alot more talent than pacman hes beat so far.

[Easy-E]

Boxingrecorddotcom has Manny as #1 P4P because they base their rankings on competition. Wright is in 2nd and PBF is, not 3rd, not 4th, heck, not even 5th, let's try 7th!

sorry man, but using boxrec as a rating system makes you lose all credibility

[Easy-E]

gatti chico castillo twice cahvez corely agustus and hernandeez thats alot more talent than pacman hes beat so far.

overall, floyd has faced better opposition in his career. pacs recent fights have been great but apart from those three names, hes faced no one. but hes top 3 imo

[czars_salad]

i have pbf at 1, pac at 2, winky at 3

these three are far above the rest. i think the matter has to be resolved both by winky and pbf with their fight(s) this year.

whatever the outcome, IMO, the three will dominate the rankings for the rest of the year

[The___Hitman]

****, Winky Wright is so overrated by a few people..

[ELPacman]

sorry man, but using boxrec as a rating system makes you lose all credibility

Well I can see your bitter and all being a PBF fan and all. Although we all have our own opinions on how the P4P rankings should be(considering they don't really mean anything), Boxrec does have a decent way. They don't look at how good the fighter really is talent wise(PBF). They are going by his competition, and where his competition stands, and I'm sure it goes through an entire system that is very calculated out. It could prove to be inaccurate at times, though I think, when you think about it, they are right. All PBF has to do is fight, let's see, um, Hatton, Cotto, Margarito, or a Tszyu comeback, and he can stand somewhere ontop. Though fighting the bums that he has doesn't make him #1 P4P. That's just common sense, talent or no talent.

[czars_salad]

****, Winky Wright is so overrated by a few people..

this has to be very daring

[czars_salad]

Well all im saying is some of the Pacman nuthuggers keep on stating how JMM was destroyed by Pacman? They must have not seen the fight, JMM outsmarted and outboxed pacman for the majority of the fight.

like backing off....

he got owned in round 11 and 12... dont get ****** by your JMM nuthugging, sucker!

[Dr.Depravity]

i have pbf at 1, pac at 2, winky at 3

these three are far above the rest. i think the matter has to be resolved both by winky and pbf with their fight(s) this year.

whatever the outcome, IMO, the three will dominate the rankings for the rest of the year

I totally agree with this order. I think Pac moved ahead of winky but PBF is still #1.

[czars_salad]

I totally agree with this order. I think Pac moved ahead of winky but PBF is still #1.

the good thing is, the #1 2 and 3 ranks are very competitive and very close, yet the thre are very much comfortable with the spots

this has to be a very good year